Contributions
354 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionAs my right hon. Friend knows, if the parties, using best endeavours, in complete sincerity with co-operation and good faith, are simply unable to agree anything, not even a few…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI do not agree with the right hon. Lady. This instrument will be deposited with the withdrawal agreement, and it contains material new obligations, which are couched in the…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI simply say to my hon. Friend that I really do not believe so. Why not? Because the commitments now cemented on alternative arrangements, which require a separate negotiating…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionThe hon. Lady can shake her head, but she has to look at the wording—at the text. If I have got something wrong, she will no doubt tell me, but the fact is that there are…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI entirely agree with my hon. Friend; the legal ingredient in any political question must be subordinate, and particularly in connection with this political question. The fact is…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI am extremely grateful to the right hon. Gentleman for his question, which I will deal with point by point. First, my opinion has changed in connection to this country’s ability…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionNo unilateral declaration is worth the paper it is written on if it is objected to. My understanding is that it is not objected to and that it will be deposited alongside the…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI know that the hon. Lady knows that I have not attempted to say something —[Interruption.] Of course there has been no amending of the treaty, but there has been a supplementary…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI do not agree. My hon. Friend knows we have a difference of opinion, and I hope that he will move towards my position. I still hope that might be so, and I say that because one…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionOf course I can confirm all those things, which are self-evident in the agreement. May I just point out to the right hon. Gentleman that although I am sure it is a clever forensic…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI do not agree with my right hon. and learned Friend, although I listen most carefully to him, as ever. The best endeavours duty was in the withdrawal agreement originally, but…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionWhat I hope will not be lost on my hon. and right hon. Friends is why the hon. and learned Lady is insisting and pressing upon them the facts and matters that she has just been…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionMy right hon. Friend has got paragraph 16 wrong, if I may respectfully say so. What it says was that I advised in the past that that was so. What I now consider, at paragraph 17,…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionThe hon. Gentleman asks me about my opinion. He knows that my opinion is that there is no ultimate unilateral right out of this arrangement. The risk of that continues, but the…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionIn my view, as a matter of law, the provisions relating to the timing of the efforts to be made in resolving withdrawal agreements make time of the essence in the negotiation of a…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionWith permission, Mr Speaker, I would like to make a statement about my legal opinion on the joint instrument and unilateral declaration concerning the withdrawal agreement…12 Mar 2019HANSARDEU Withdrawal Agreement: Northern IrelandWe will endeavour to give as much notice as we possibly can. Of course those discussions are running. They will resume very shortly and continue almost certainly through the…07 Mar 2019HANSARDEU Withdrawal Agreement: Northern IrelandThe hon. Gentleman knows that if I were to answer that question, I would be breaching the Law Officers’ convention. All I can say is that I turn my mind to a great many of the…07 Mar 2019HANSARDLeaving the EUThe hon. Lady knows that she is asking me questions that belong to the Department for Transport, not to me. These matters do not come to the Law Officers unless they have a Law…07 Mar 2019HANSARDLeaving the EUThe priorities of my Office are published in the business plan. In relation to the UK’s withdrawal from the Union, my priority continues to be supporting the successfully delivery…07 Mar 2019