Contributions
354 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionThe right hon. Gentleman seeks to give with one hand and take with the other. With the greatest of diffidence and respect, he is not quite right. The unilateral declaration is not…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionOf course, claims are made on both sides of the argument in any election or battle before the electorate. I remember some pretty exaggerated ones being made on the hon.…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionNo, I do not agree. The position is more nuanced than that. The pattern of refusing to accept reasonable proposals such as alternative arrangements that could not be said to…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI am not convinced that I fully understood the question, perhaps because I did it too much justice and thought it might be a sensible one. The truth is that I doubt I agree with…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI understand my hon. Friend’s frustrations, but I do not agree with his language. I have found those with whom we are doing business in the European Union to be perfectly…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionThe hon. Gentleman is not right about that. Under article 184 of the withdrawal agreement, there is a legal duty on the Union and the UK to negotiate a deal that is in line, and…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionYes, I do. Given what is at stake for the people of Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, for the credit and faith of the European Union, which will be on the line, and…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionIt does make perfect sense. I have to say that I would have preferred to have seen a right of termination, mitigated and graduated, fairly balancing and apportioning risk, and…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI will try to obey the hon. Lady’s strictures about comments that I have made before. May I say to her that that is not quite right? I have said that the legal risk is reduced.…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionFirst, may I say to my right hon. Friend that I am extremely grateful for the dialogue that we have had and he was, in no small part, the author of the seeds of this idea. Much of…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionNo, no, no. We have not been attempting to secure alternative arrangements now. We have been putting forward the fact that, in the future, all those alternative arrangements are…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionNo, no, no. What I said to my hon. Friend the Member for North East Somerset (Mr Rees-Mogg) was that we would not do it in breach of the law. We are permitted, in a case of…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionLet me make it clear: the United Kingdom is the United Kingdom, it includes Northern Ireland and there is no circumstance in which the Government of this country, and certainly…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionWe have made a solemn pledge to the people of both Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland that the border will be guaranteed never to be a hard border. That required the…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionWell, my hon. Friend will know that as an Attorney General I simply could not give countenance to the idea that this country would break its international legal obligations. As I…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI think I had better just say that I agree with that one.12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI would need to see the hon. Lady’s quotation in detail. The position is that if you agree and put your name to a joint instrument of this kind, you are bound by it. You are bound…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionAnd so it was under that particular Prime Minister! I was telling the hon. Gentleman the complete truth, as I am telling him it now. I have forgotten what the other question…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionI entirely agree with my hon. Friend on that. With the law, we are not able to put something into a test tube, hold it over a Bunsen burner and, if it turns green, get the answer.…12 Mar 2019HANSARDWithdrawal Agreement: Legal OpinionThe hon. Gentleman will forgive me for saying that I am afraid I am not permitted by the Law Officers’ convention to say whether I gave advice or what advice that would be.12 Mar 2019