Contributions
813 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)But a bit like an iceberg, the transfer of wealth from group A to group B is somewhere else; it is not here in the impact assessment. Jack Spearman: Agreed. Also, in terms of the…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Can I ask you about the discount rates that are used? We have the deferment rate and the capitalisation rate. Those will be determined in secondary legislation as well. Do you…18 Jan 2024HANSARDDraft Public Offers and Admissions to Trading Regulations 2023
Draft Securitisation Regulations 2023
Draft Financial Services Act 2021 (Overseas Funds Regime and Recognition of Parts of Schemes) (Amendment and Modification) Regulations 2024
Draft Data Reporting Services Regulations 2023I want to follow up on the comment from my right hon. Friend the Member for East Yorkshire on the role of the FCA. The Minister will be aware of the concerns of Members on the…17 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)That is very helpful. I will stop there, but I want to come back on discount rates later if I have time. Professor Leunig: Excellent.16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q What is clear, though, is that the business net present value is scored at minus £1.7 billion, so presumably we can pretty much say that the impact on business is going to be—…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q That is helpful to know. Therefore, does redistribution matter—it could be a social good or not—and does it matter who and how that redistribution happens? Are those things…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q The top line says that the best estimate of present value is £90 million, but then it says that the low estimate is minus £1.5 billion and the high estimate is £1.5 billion.…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q So the geographic dimension—there are more leasehold properties in London—and the redistribution argument is stronger than the “all properties in London are expensive compared…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q I am interested because so many other purchase decisions—indeed the mortgage you get—will be subject to market rates at that time. Those rates can go up and down, and that will…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q And that was the Law Commission’s objective. Professor Hopkins: The terms of reference that we agreed with Government for the project in relation to premium were that we would…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q Is it right to say that this Bill is a wealth transfer from rich freeholders to rich leaseholders? This is primarily just moving money between rich people, isn’t it? Professor…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q I think we can look at strengthening some of the provisions at the start and at the end, in terms of the rights if someone wants to sell their property and how people are leant…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q Actually, I was trying to say that we should stop it altogether because— Halima Ali: Oh right, sorry—16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q So it is redistributive, primarily. It sounds that way from those numbers, but there may be some hidden benefits that have not been monetised in the report. That is helpful.…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (First sitting)Q From that, are you implying that your view is that it has been a rip-off to date, and therefore there are monies that you should have been having for all the years you have been…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)That was very helpful; thank you very much.16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q So this is a London wealth transfer. Professor Leunig: That will be the biggest—16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)I was not being very clear, I am sorry—it is my job to be clear, not yours. I think what you were saying is that this is trying to fix the problem, but the root of the problem is…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q The whole issue of adoption may or may not be in scope, but there were some other suggestions that you had, such as that estate management charges may not include fees for areas…16 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Second sitting)Q Well, let me draw on that. The core of this is something I mentioned earlier. If you look at the benefits, there is a total of £2.8 billion of impact monetised, which is under a…16 Jan 2024