Contributions
813 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q We have been talking a bit about regulation, which is often seen as some sort of answer to problems and frequently is not—or, at least, is different from simplification or…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q When you say “regulated”, do you mean they should have a qualification—that they can tick a box to say, “I was qualified to do this”—or redress, as in, there is a regulatory…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q My questions are for Professor Hodges. We have to deal with the Bill as it is—on the commonhold thing—so, “Get it done” is not particularly helpful, if I may say. It might be a…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)I will come to that in a minute. But just in here, on this Bill, is there anything that we should look out for? Professor Hodges: As far as the detail is concerned, there is…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Okay, so more generally then, on regulators—Ofgem on energy prices and Ofwat on sewage and water—that approach seems not to provide the outcomes that perhaps were originally…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Rules, codes, systems, data, penalties, redress, different organisations—this is your answer as a better solution to caveat emptor? Professor Hodges: Yes, absolutely. Now, let me…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)In all circumstances or specifically on this Bill? Well, we ought to stick to the Bill. I just want to be clear: you have just outlined the solution—this Bill is going part of the…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I want to follow on from the point made by my colleague, Mike Amesbury, about your November report. When it looked at estate management charges, there was a litany of abuses…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q My concern is that you are going to finish your report, quite rightly, in the fullness of time—that will be February—and this Committee will not be sitting in February; heaven…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Let me attempt to get back on to Conservative territory, rather than Barry’s territory. There are many experts in this field, and campaigners have done some fantastic work. I am…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q That did not quite answer my question. My question was: is marriage value a real thing? It could be large or small. Can you describe what it is and do you perceive that it is a…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I have one final question, if I may. I know it is not quite at a stroke, because I think it is when they come up, but is there any way of mitigating? It seems to me that when…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Oh, it is much wider than that. James Vitali: Indeed. I think a balancing act needs to be struck in this Bill between spreading genuine property rights more widely and…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Exactly.18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Very good. Does anyone else want to come in? I had another question, unless we have no more time.18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Our previous witness, Mr Vitali, talked about potential concerns about the effect of regulation on people’s understanding of property rights. Do you have any significant…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)On a point of order, Dame Caroline. I am wondering whether my colleague, Mr Gardiner, is getting to a question rather than just expressing a view.18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Perhaps Mr Gardiner will call a point of order on me. I have been talking about this transfer of value. There are non-monetised here, but there is £1.9 billion of transfer. I…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Q So just to be clear, as the Committee considers this Bill, including what may come from subsequent secondary legislation, it is not £1.9 billion of transfer, but £1.9 billion…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Fourth sitting)Exactly—you have added them all up. I just did the first section. Jack Spearman: Indeed.18 Jan 2024