Contributions
1,262 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDRailways BillMy Lords, I hope that I can be relatively brief, because my noble friends have explained that the two opposing views—they are not really opposing but—21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillIt is a fair question. People listening to this from outside might ask, given that GBR runs the infrastructure and services, what the point is of one bit of the business charging…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillJust before my noble friend sits down, may I add to the point he has made? The noble Lord, Lord Faulkner of Worcester, as did the noble Lord, Lord Tunnicliffe, illustrated one of…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillOn that point, as the Minister has concluded that little section, I am grateful that he said that he is prepared to reflect on this. But the speech of the noble Lord, Lord…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillMy Lords, first, I congratulate my noble friend Lord Parkinson of Whitley Bay on his ingenuity in managing to get amendments on heritage railways into many groups in the Bill, and…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillIf I may intervene briefly before the Minister moves on, he said that he is satisfied that the Government have given or will give the pension scheme sufficient notice. Can he…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillI thank my colleague for a more diplomatic way of expressing it. Fundamentally, the provision set out in the Bill—the plain vanilla judicial review—goes too far in one direction.…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillMy Lords, I will speak to four amendments in this group, most of them relatively briefly. I support Amendment 213, moved by my noble friend Lord Moylan, who clearly set out the…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillMy Lords, I will limit my remarks to the three amendments in the names of the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, to which I have attached my name. The reason that I support these…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillBefore we move on, first, I want to clarify something briefly; the Chair has already done this, I think. It was made very clear to the House by the committee that set out the…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillMy Lords, I shall speak relatively briefly to this group since we covered some of these issues in the previous group. I reiterate my congratulations to my noble friend Lord…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillJust to be clear, there are two different things going on here. What the Minister is talking about—he is right that it is covered by the second part of Clause 64(5)—is the charges…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillJust so that the Minister does not end up reflecting on the wrong things, and to be clear, I think that my noble friend and I agree that having that slightly wider test is…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillYes, we did.21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillMy Lords, I have some questions in this section, as my noble friend Lord Young had. Like him, I broadly agree with the thrust of my noble friend Lord Moylan’s amendments; they are…21 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillMy Lords, I will speak to four amendments in this group. The first is Amendment 188A in the name of my noble friend Lord Moylan; I can be very brief on this one. It makes the…19 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillI really do not follow this argument at all. If DPTAC has two advisory roles, in advising both the Secretary of State and GBR, having an extra advisory role will not in any way…19 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillMy Lords, there are a couple of areas that I want to focus on. First, I strongly support my noble friend Lord Moylan’s Amendment 161, insisting that, in the rail strategy,…19 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillI take the noble Baroness’s point, but my point was not about removing the ability of staff to sell tickets; it was to enable them to be more flexibly deployed. For example, one…19 Oct 2026HANSARDRailways BillIf the Minister will forgive me—19 Oct 2026