213: After Clause 58, insert the following new Clause—
“Driver-only operation on new GBR passenger services(1) A new GBR passenger service may be provided only if it is operated on a driver-only basis.(2) Great British Railways and every GBR company must exercise their functions relating to—(a) the planning and introduction of GBR passenger services,(b) the award and performance of public service contracts, and(c) the preparation of working timetables,so as to secure compliance with subsection (1).(3) The ORR may exempt a new GBR passenger service from subsection (1) only where it is satisfied that driver-only operation would create an unacceptable risk to the safe operation of the railway.(4) In this section, “driver-only” means operation without the necessary presence of a guard.”Member's explanatory statement
This amendment would require all new GBR passenger services to operate on a driver-only basis, subject only to a limited safety exemption granted by the ORR.
213: After Clause 58, insert the following new Clause—
“Driver-only operation on new GBR passenger services(1) A new GBR passenger service may be provided only if it is operated on a driver-only basis.(2) Great British Railways and every GBR company must exercise their functions relating to—(a) the planning and introduction of GBR passenger services,(b) the award and performance of public service contracts, and(c) the preparation of working timetables,so as to secure compliance with subsection (1).(3) The ORR may exempt a new GBR passenger service from subsection (1) only where it is satisfied that driver-only operation would create an unacceptable risk to the safe operation of the railway.(4) In this section, “driver-only” means operation without the necessary presence of a guard.”Member's explanatory statement
This amendment would require all new GBR passenger services to operate on a driver-only basis, subject only to a limited safety exemption granted by the ORR.
My Lords, this group of amendments is a bit of a ragbag, covering a broad and diverse range of topics. I hope noble Lords will understand if I take the full time available to me or something close to that in order to cover at least those amendments which stand in my name.
Amendment 213 would require new passenger services provided by Great British Railways to operate on a driver-only basis. As I have said before, there is something tremendously backward-looking about this legislation, when we think about the lack of anything in it about new technology and the way of working that the new Great British Railways might adopt. One of those respects is working practices. We have seen very recently with Chiltern Railways the RMT once again objecting to proposals for driver-only operation on new east-west rail services. I appreciate that Chiltern Railways has recently had its franchise terminated, but on other of its services, driver-only operation works very satisfactorily. As an occasional customer of Chiltern Railways, travelling to Solihull and Birmingham, I am very aware of that. I am not saying that that is the only reason why the east-west rail service is not operating this way, but it is a significant point. The RMT argues that the arrangements water down safety, because a second member of staff would necessarily perform a safety-critical train manager role.
However, Chiltern has confirmed that every east-west rail service will still have two people on board: the driver, and another colleague responsible for looking after passengers, checking tickets, assisting those who need help and dealing with issues on board. Chiltern has also made it clear that it has operated most of its trains with the driver controlling the doors for decades.
That brings me to the purpose of this amendment. If we are creating Great British Railways, we should also be looking seriously, as I say, at how the railway can operate more efficiently. The noble Lord will probably say that this is all a matter to be entrusted to Great British Railways once it is up and running, but it is one in which the public and Parliament have a very legitimate interest, and it would not be inappropriate to have something along these lines on the face of the Bill. We should not automatically preserve working practices simply because they have existed historically, particularly where technology and modern operating practices mean that they are no longer necessary. Driver-only and driver-controlled operation are hardly novel concepts. The independent safety regulator has previously concluded that with suitable equipment, proper procedures and competent staff in place, driver-only operation can be a safe method of working. The ORR’s current guidance similarly makes it clear that driver-controlled operation can meet legal safety requirements where the proper systems and safeguards are in place.
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 306A, which seeks a commitment from the Government to ensure that train companies bear the cost of training, licensing and certification of train drivers. The Bill in its present form can enable the current or future Secretary of State to introduce fees for drivers receiving or renewing their licence and/or train-driving certificate. This would create a financial barrier to increasing the supply of train drivers.
A fee system for drivers could discourage job applications, especially from younger applicants, at a time when the Government have lowered the train-driving age to 18. A shortage of drivers leads to an overreliance on overtime to keep the railway system running; given this and an increased number of retirements in the near future, there is no need to add any barriers to the process of recruiting new drivers.
4:30 pm
If GBR is proposed as the licence issuer, drivers working for employers outside of GBR—in freight, in open access or under devolved authorities—could be forced to pay a fee to the infrastructure manager and operators of passenger services, on top of their employer paying access charges. In a recent survey, which elicited 5,000 responses, 94% of ASLEF drivers opposed the introduction of fees for licensing and 95% did not support fees for certificates. The majority said that they would have been less likely to apply for the job if they had had to pay fees for their licence.
This amendment seeks clarity and certainty. I suspect that the Minister might respond by saying that the Government have no intention to charge individuals. If so, that should be stated clearly in the Bill and this should set a benchmark in case a future Government are tempted to introduce personal fees. I am well aware that the current Bill requires the Government to consult with train drivers and others, but it has no requirement stronger than saying “have regard to”. That is the phrase used, so after consultation it is not beyond the realms of possibility that the views of train drivers and their representatives would be disregarded. We all remember the minimum service levels legislation: in 2023, the Government consulted but, despite opposition, went ahead with the legislation anyway. Some people say that they did not have regard to the views expressed and, subsequently, the legislation could not be implemented. It was simply impractical.
This amendment seeks certainty and clarity from the Government. It asks Parliament to define who may be charged for licensing and certification. The Government state that they have no intention to charge any individual. It would be helpful for the Minister to confirm this by accepting this very modest amendment to the Bill.
My Lords, I am going to speak to Amendment 330C in my name. I declare, as this is the first time I have spoken today, that I am a teacher in a state school. I am not sure if I have to declare this, but I am an officer on the APPG on Apprenticeships, which has a bearing on this.
We are in a skills crisis. We no longer have to explain what NEET stands for. We all know. We have just had the Milburn report and the zeitgeist is very much that we need to do something about it.
The Armed Forces are the biggest provider of apprenticeships in this country and the Army is the largest part; it has about 90,000 people working for it, which I believe is about the same number as Great British Railways will have. I think that your Lordships can see where I am going: I would like Great British Railways to commit to becoming the largest provider of apprenticeships as a proportion of its workers. It is based around the country and, when the railways were formed, they were one of the biggest employers in the country. I think that this would be the perfect opportunity to work around the country with organisations such as Skills England, local mayoral authorities and local skills improvement plans to provide a highly motivated, highly skilled and faithful workforce. I think that the Prime Minister might like it as well.
My Lords, I will speak to four amendments in this group, most of them relatively briefly. I support Amendment 213, moved by my noble friend Lord Moylan, who clearly set out the reasons for it. I add only that it is a useful amendment because it effectively changes the presumption, which is helpful for GBR. It would still allow the ORR to say that you need not have driver-only operation if there is a very good reason for doing so, but it would mean that the default is that you would have it.
This comes back to a discussion we had the other day. If you are going to run a competitive railway and deliver it at a reasonable cost, the advantage of staff not doing jobs that can be done more efficiently is that this frees up GBR to deploy its staff in a way that better serves customers. I briefly refer to our discussion on Monday about the need to have more staff focused on supporting passengers with disabilities and other needs. There are only so many people to go around and there is only so much cost that can be borne, and delivering this driver-only operation more efficiently enables GBR to deploy staff to serving passengers in the way we wanted to see when we discussed this on Monday.
All I add to my noble friend Lord Moylan’s Amendment 305A on pensions is that it is not just important, in getting this transition right, to protect employees’ rights and financial benefits. That is of course very important, and his amendment does that. The second thing about having a proper transitional process is making sure that the management of what is a large pension scheme is efficient. Sadly, with the management of Civil Service pensions moving from one provider to another, we have already seen that, if that is not well handled, current employees trying to find information about their pensions and people who are retiring and need that information get a very poor service. If the pension scheme is forced into a transitional process too quickly, not only does that put at risk ensuring that the financial rights of pensioners are protected but it potentially delivers terrible customer service, which can be incredibly damaging for pensioners. Making sure that that is handled in a sensible and orderly way is beneficial for both GBR and its workforce. There is no interest for anybody in having that not well handled.
My Lords, I have a couple of comments on this group of amendments. The first is on Amendment 213 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan. It is very sensible, to the extent that we have lots of passenger trains sitting in sidings doing nothing. East West Rail comes to mind, and at Waterloo station there are several hundred trains which have been there for a number of years because there is no agreement on whether the driver is able to close the door or it needs to be somebody else. Of course, it is not about anything particularly relevant to this service and it seems to have got caught up in the web of obfuscation. I am interested to know from my noble friend what arrangements are being made for the new trans-Pennine services and whether they will have a driver or a guard to shut the door, and whether the driver will not shut the door and the guard will also do the very important duties elsewhere on the train. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s comments on that.
Amendment 319, on minimum service, is important. Those of us who have studied the goings-on in France over the last few decades—not at the moment—always came away with the impression that there was a railway strike happening somewhere in the country. That was probably true most of the time, because most of the strikes were very small, and regional or local in application. However, the one thing that the Government and SNCF have done more recently is to require SNCF to run a minimum service on the main lines, even if the rest of their people are on strike—some of my family got caught up in this in years past. It is something like running one train in three or one train in four, which inconveniences many passengers but means that those who need to get around for some important reason, even if there is a delay, can do it. I hope my noble friend will look at that as an option for dealing with the worst effect of strikes if they ever happen.
Finally, Amendment 330C in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, is on apprenticeships, and of course I fully support it. I have been trying to encourage firms in Cornwall in the maritime sector to take on more apprenticeships. They have had many discussions with Skills England and have taken on a number of apprenticeships, which is very good for the area. Skills England recently cancelled its apprenticeships and said there was no demand. As there were several students already doing it, that seems a bit odd. I am in touch with our colleague the Minister on this, but I hope that, in the apprenticeships seen in the railway sector, we take this extremely seriously and try to cover as much of the country as we can. In the future we will need these people to replace some of the older members of the team.
My Lords, my noble friend Lord Bradshaw is not able to be in his place today, so he has asked me to speak to his Amendment 308, to which I have added my name, and which concerns Clause 94.
Most train drivers have a staff history that follows them as they move through the system. It is updated as they qualify for different sorts of track and rolling stock, and their route knowledge is also recorded and updated. This is the responsibility of the company employing them, and it works as it is. My noble friend Lord Bradshaw strongly feels that it should not need to be altered. The small number of drivers involved in running trains in France and beyond need licences, which should be the responsibility of their employers; of course, these are mainly Eurostar, Eurotunnel and freight drivers. My noble friend is really concerned. He can see no purpose in a central register containing drivers’ details. He thinks this will create far more bureaucracy in the system, which he says would be better avoided. It will be interesting to hear the Minister’s thoughts on my noble friend’s amendment.
I turn to a couple of other amendments in this group. On Amendment 330C in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, I fully support the idea of having far more apprenticeships on the railway. In fact, my father started his career with an apprenticeship on the railway, working in Eastleigh in Hampshire. He then qualified as a carpenter and a joiner, working on freight containers before moving on to a teaching career. My family has a history of this, and I think it is really important, particularly as young people are currently struggling to find careers. This is a way to have high-quality jobs, some of them very technical. I hope that Great British Railways will support this, as have other big projects, such as Crossrail in London.
I remind the Committee that, as per paragraph 4.29 of the Companion, interventions should be brief and questions should be asked for clarification only. Speeches should not be made, so I ask noble Lords seeking to intervene to keep their contributions concise. Thank you.
20 of 289 shown
This amendment therefore establishes a clear presumption that the new GBR passenger services should operate on a driver-only basis. That would allow GBR to design new services around modern and efficient operating practices from the outset, rather than importing unnecessary staffing requirements into every new service. Bear in mind, of course, that GBR will be much more vulnerable to industrial action in the future if, as has been discussed on other groups, there is an eventual drift—as I am sure there will be if the unions get their way—to a single employer.
Crucially, however, the amendment has a safety override, because it includes a provision in proposed new subsection (3) expressly giving the ORR the power to exempt a service from this requirement when it is satisfied that driver-only operation would create an unacceptable risk to the safe operation of the railway. If Great British Railways is genuinely going to deliver a more efficient railway, it must have the ability to modernise the way in which new services are operated, while maintaining the higher standards of safety.
Turning to Amendments 305A and 305B, Amendment 305A is about ensuring that, as employees move into the new structure, existing employment liabilities move with them in an orderly and transparent way. This amendment has been tabled by me at the urging of Railpen, the body that manages the railways pension scheme. I am sure that it has made similar representations to the Government, and I wish to hear how the Government have responded to them. Nearly everybody who works on the railway has a pension scheme. There are multiple schemes, but nearly all of them come under the umbrella of the same railways pension scheme, and their management agent goes under the name of Railpen. It has explained clearly that if there is to be a transition of staff and the pension —the liability mentioned here—is to travel with them, it needs a considerable run-in period to manage that in a legally safe way, to ensure that there are no questions about the entitlement to a pension that a staff member has accrued. It estimates a minimum of 12 months’ notice; that is what was said to me—it may have a firmer figure it can put on the table in conversations with the Government, but there is approximately 12 months’ clarity. This amendment would build that clarity into the Bill, and it is a very important consideration for staff. Whatever the Government’s plans may be—and I do not think there are any at the moment—for the pensions of future railway staff, those who have in good faith accumulated an entitlement to date should not have it put at legal risk, even temporarily, by a botched and hasty transition. This amendment seeks to prevent that happening.
Turning to Amendment 305B, there needs to be much greater clarity, for similar reasons, about the corporate and employer structure of Great British Railways, including where employees will sit and how these pension arrangements will work. Further detail on the proposed structure and implementation timetable is vital if the Government’s commitments are to be delivered effectively in practice. Without clear and timely information, there is a greater risk to employee outcomes, effective governance and long-term sustainability of pension arrangements. This is not the sort of amendment that, even if we were on Report, I would currently want to press. It is designed to elicit clear commitments from the Minister in Committee at the Dispatch Box that will satisfy Railpen and the beneficiaries of the pension schemes.
Turning to Amendment 306, the Minister in the other place said that the Government have no plans to remove the ORR from its role in train driver licensing and certification, but added that a future Government might need to alter who performs that function, following changes to industry structures and responsibilities. Why? Why would any circumstance arise that would remove the power of licensing and certification from the ORR, the independent safety regulator? We have been assured that, although the ORR’s position is being greatly diminished in some respects, in regard to safety its power and authority remain untouched and sacrosanct. In what circumstances would the Government imagine this coming about? This amendment is designed to ensure that they cannot do that, but it gives the Minister an opportunity to explain why the Government would want this power in the first place and to see whether noble Lords would accept that explanation.
Amendments 319, 320 and 342 go to the wider problem that the Government are creating for industrial relations on the railway. The first would restore minimum service levels during strike action. The Government chose to repeal the Strikes (Minimum Service Levels) Act through the Employment Rights Act 2025, removing the framework that was intended to protect a basic level of service for passengers during industrial action. As I said a moment ago, the risk of a national industrial strike is greatly enhanced by this legislation, The requirement that there should be appropriate thresholds for ballots to take place and that there should be a minimum service level, as required by the previous legislation, seems the barest minimum that the Government should do in order to protect passengers and the travelling public.
Amendment 320 is on a workforce productivity framework. It is also very important. If Great British Railways is to deliver better value for taxpayers and passengers—that must be and is one of its objectives—it cannot simply absorb existing working practices without challenging whether they remain appropriate. If there is one all-singing and all-dancing Great British Railways that is in charge, that should be set to music in a plan that can be scrutinised and challenged.
When you had multiple employers and the fragmentation that the Minister so deplores, one can understand how it is difficult to draw all that together. But one of the great advantages, if there are any advantages, to GBR is that it should be put to the challenge on exactly the question of how it is going to improve workforce productivity. It is not enough to say, “Leave it to us”. We need a serious programme of workforce modernisation.
Finally, Amendment 318 is not in my name, if I am correct, but my noble friend Lord Grayling is unfortunately not able to be here for the early part of the Committee, although I believe that he is going to join us later. This is an amendment in his name that he has asked me to mention, which I am pleased to do. It concerns the training of staff in relation to railways—people working on the railways and people who might want to work on the railways in the future. He proposes the merits of a national rail college or academy. It does not necessarily have to be in one building in one place—modern educational systems have more diversity to them than that. It would be a national railways academy to help train and improve existing staff, but also to encourage newcomers and to create pathways, partly through apprenticeships and partly through graduate routes, to encourage people coming on to the railway.
Again, if there is any advantage in having Great British Railways as a single operator, it would be the possibility to move forward with bold ideas such as that, which can set a fresh path for the railways, encourage young people and give them hope and aspiration to work on the railways, which can be, as I think we all know, a very rewarding and enjoyable career. I beg to move.
I support Amendment 320 on workforce productivity, which my noble friend set out well. We talked a lot about costs and who bears the cost of that—the taxpayer or the fare payer—but the important point is to reduce the cost of delivering rail services so that, however we split that cost, it is as low as possible for both taxpayer and fare payer. My noble friend sets out a good scheme for doing so.
I absolutely support the thrust of Amendment 330C, to which the noble Lord, Lord Hampton, just spoke. If he were to bring it back on Report, depending on what the Minister says, the wording would need tightening up, because he said he wanted GBR to be the largest provider of apprenticeships as a proportion of its workforce, which is not what the amendment currently says. I support the first part of it, which is about increasing the number of apprenticeships, but I am not sure that having a target for GBR to be the biggest one is a sensible thing to write into statute.
The thrust of the noble Lord’s amendment was to have GBR become a significant provider of apprenticeships across, importantly, the whole of its workforce, not just what is currently the Network Rail side—the engineering side and people delivering the infrastructure—but the whole business, including customer services and some of the back-office operations, such as finance and managing it. All those provide great jobs for people and training for that workforce. As the noble Lord, Lord Sikka, mentioned, a significant number are getting towards retirement age, and training a workforce and making sure that we have a workforce for the future is valuable. I commend that amendment to the Committee.
The amendment in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Grayling, on a national rail training and technology academy, is really interesting. A tunnelling academy was developed as part of Crossrail, and we know that there are many issues around driver training, shortages and using new technology in the railway. The suggestion from the noble Lord is welcome, and I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response.