Contributions
1,800 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q I think we will probably be coming back to that as we discuss the Bill line by line. Finally, what is your definition of the difference between what you have just described and…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q It is beginning to sound to me like the difference will come down to whether it is intentional or unintentional. Professor Henderson: It is to do with intentionality, but it is…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)We are losing you, but I get the drift. I will leave it there.28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q Good morning and welcome. You may have heard some of the previous discussion around labelling. Indeed, it is something the Food Standards Agency has looked into. Could you tell…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q Could you say a little bit more about distinctions between the new nutritional labelling and the other labelling? I think that is important for the Committee to understand.…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q May I press you on one final example that has been brought to my attention? It is one of a tomato that could be genetically edited to boost vitamin D content, for instance, and…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q All that is very interesting and very good, but I do not actually see that this is covered in the Bill as it stands. This is all going to have to follow through secondary…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q I have two sets of questions. First, I want to go back to labelling, because I have been mulling over your response. Is the objection to labelling the two apples that you…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q I get that, but if there were a genetic marker that you could identify, would that give you a mechanism for doing that? Professor May: In principle. There are ways that you…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q Thank you, that is helpful. My second question is about the register established by the Bill, which the Food Standards Agency is required to maintain. The Bill is fairly light…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q I am slightly sceptical here. I imagine one of my constituents going into a garage and buying a chocolate bar that was produced with some genetically edited sugar grown in…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q But that is the difference between having it on a label and on a register, isn’t it? A register requires a bigger effort to check, frankly. Professor May: There is a slight…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q But as far as you understand it, the purpose of the register is to give that public reassurance. It is a public information issue. Professor May: That is correct, yes.28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q Welcome and good morning, Professor Dunwell. I am going to try to pursue some of the vexed issues of definition at the start of the Bill, and I will ask you first the question…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Q That is helpful. The problem that I and others have with the Bill is that it was explained to us at the outset as addressing a particular issue—allowing gene editing within one…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (First sitting)Thank you. I will leave it there for the moment.28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Second sitting)I think we might find some examples, but that is for another day.28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Second sitting)Q I start by thanking you and your colleagues for your excellent evidence, some of it submitted to the consultation. It has certainly informed a lot of our thinking, although it…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Second sitting)Q Let me press you on that slightly. In terms of some of the animal welfare issues, it is pretty clear that some of the things that could be done could be designed to make animals…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Second sitting)Q That is a really important point. I may be wrong, but I do not see anything in the Bill enabling that. Professor Lovell-Badge: Nor do I. Alessandro Coatti: Under clause 11, when…28 Jun 2022