Contributions
1,800 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Well, it highlights the concerns that we have. Going on from that, my next question is on the terms “precision bred organism” and—this is not in the Bill, but it is related to…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q In your earlier answer to the Minister, you—I think rightly—pointed out that this Bill does not add anything in terms of intellectual property rights. In the absence of the Bill…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Thank you for joining us this afternoon, Mr Houston. Aquaculture is slightly different—I assume you are talking about the farmed sector—as there is always the issue of escape…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I can see the potential benefits, but I am slightly worried about the potential risk in the wider natural world, and I do not see anything in the Bill as it stands to either…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Basically, I can absolutely see the benefits, but I can also see risks, and it is the risk side that I am worried about. What I am asking you is whether you can see anything in…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q That is fine. I am certainly not laying it on you; it is down to us to come up with the answer to that one. Ross Houston: Yes, but my practical point would be—this is the way we…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)That is a very sobering prospect. Thank you; that was helpful.30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Welcome to all of you, particularly the representative from NIAB. I have three quick questions, if we could rattle through them with each of you. First, you will all recall the…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q This will only take a second. I am trying to conclude this long and interesting discussion about liability. I think what you are saying is that in the end it will require…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q You have probably answered some of my questions already, but I am going to explore some of those points further. If I understood you correctly, the risk is that if we end up…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q So you are saying it depends on the FSA’s approvals process. What would need to be in this Bill to give the levels of reassurance that you would be looking for? Ed Barker: In…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q But that is not in the Bill as it stands, is it? Professor Harwood: It is not, but I think that would probably fall under part 3, which looks at food safety. I imagine that it…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Not in yours, but possibly in others who are less public spirited. Nigel Moore: I think the critical answer to the question is that public confidence and reassurance is at the…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q One final question for the moment: to the lay observer, these flows backwards and forwards between different countries and within the UK are quite staggering. I may be…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Good afternoon and welcome. I do not know how much of a chance you have had to look at the details of the Bill, but it proposes a notification system and a public register. How…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q On labelling and transparency, you have probably seen the research from the Food Standards Agency showing that the public would like to know more about where their food comes…30 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Second sitting)Q I will follow up on that, in that case. If there is that confidence, why the reluctance to allow consumers to know how their food is being produced? Polling from the Food…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Second sitting)Which begs the question of why you had to register. However, I think we could probably go round in circles on this. Chair, I am quite happy for us to move on to other questioners.28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Second sitting)Q There seems to be a slight inconsistency to me, though. Dr Harrison : That is why I was saying that, at the time of planting, people can choose. The supply chain fits around…28 Jun 2022HANSARDGenetic Technology (Precision Breeding) Bill (Second sitting)Q What do you think the purpose of the registers are, in that case? Dr Harrison: Everybody has said, and many panels have shown, that there is a need, when you are bringing a new…28 Jun 2022