E-petition 754331 relating to an independent review of Council Tax and Stamp Duty Land Tax
There will be a Westminster Hall debate on 23 November 2026 calling for the government to commission a review of council tax and stamp duty.
E-petition 754331 calls for the government to commission a full, independent review of council tax and stamp duty. The petition said:
Council Tax arrears have risen to £8.3 billion, with more than two million households struggling to keep up. We believe a tax based on 1990s property values no longer reflects today’s homes or people’s ability to pay — and it fails to provide a stable way to fund essential local services.
We believe Stamp Duty remains a narrow, one-off tax that distorts the housing market and traps families in unsuitable homes.
The petition closed on 23 July 2026 and gathered 101,190 signatures.
Government responseThe UK Government responds to all e-petitions that receive over 10,000 signatures. The government’s response published on the petition page on 13 April 2026 said that council tax and stamp duty are both important sources of government revenue, “raising £60 billion a year to fund essential services”. The government response also said:
We recognise that owners of the most valuable homes in England pay proportionately far less tax on their properties compared to those in lower value homes. That is why at the Autumn Budget, the Chancellor set out a new High Value Council Tax Surcharge that will be introduced in 2028/29. This will apply a £2,500 surcharge for properties worth over £2m and a £7,500 surcharge for properties worth over £5m to be collected alongside council tax. Revenue will be used to support funding for local government services, with further detail set to be set out at the next Spending Review. Current council tax bands will not be affected and will still apply.
We want the council tax system to be fair for taxpayers and local authorities and will continue to keep it under review.
What are council tax and stamp duty?Council tax and stamp duty are both taxes on domestic properties.
Council taxCouncil tax is collected by the local billing authority (the district council or unitary authority) and is generally paid by the occupier of a property in 10 or 12 monthly instalments each year.
Properties are split into eight bands (Bands A-H). In England, the bands are based on properties’ estimated sale value on 1 April 1991. Properties in England have not been revalued since council tax was introduced in 1993. In Wales, bands are based on properties' estimated sale value on 1 April 2003.
Properties pay the same council tax as other properties in the same band under the same billing authority, but different billing authorities charge different rates. For example, for 2026/27 Dorset Council is charging £2,625.43 a year in council tax for a Band D property, while Wandsworth Council is charging £1,020.35.
These rates reflect the cost of providing services in each local area balanced against the income available to each billing authority from other sources, such as business rates income or central government grants. Historical decisions made by each billing authority also have an impact, as billing authorities can only raise council tax by a maximum percentage each year without triggering a local referendum.
Council tax is a devolved policy area. The Scottish and Welsh Governments set council tax policy in Scotland and Wales, while a separate domestic rating system operates in Northern Ireland.
The UK Government has announced that, from April 2028, it will also charge a High Value Council Tax Surcharge on domestic properties in England worth £2 million or more. The surcharge would begin at £2,500 a year and would increase for more expensive properties, up to a maximum of £7,500 a year for properties worth over £5 million. The surcharge would be paid in addition to households’ existing council tax bills. The government has not yet legislated to create this surcharge.
Stamp dutyStamp duty land tax (commonly called stamp duty) is collected by HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) and is paid by the buyer on the purchase of a domestic or non-domestic property.
For domestic properties, stamp duty is charged on a ‘slice’ basis, with different tax rates charged on different portions of the overall property price. The first slice of the property price (up to £125,000) is charged at 0%, rising gradually up to 12% for any amount paid over £1,500,000.
Reliefs are available to first-time buyers who purchase a property worth no more than £500,000. In this case, a buyer pays 0% stamp duty on the first £300,000 and 5% on the remainder of the property price. Additional stamp duty is due for people who own multiple properties, and there can be a stamp duty surcharge for buyers who are not UK residents.
Stamp duty is a devolved tax and only applies to property transactions in England and Northern Ireland. Scotland and Wales have their own land transaction taxes.
Why are there calls to review council tax and stamp duty?Critics argue that council tax is regressive, as it charges less for more expensive properties relative to their value. Properties in the highest band (Band H) are charged three times the rate of properties in the lowest band (Band A). However, when council tax bands were set in 1991, Band H properties were worth on average eight times as much as Band A properties, and the difference in value is often larger today as house price growth has varied across the country. According to the Institute for Fiscal Studies in 2024, "at least half" of households are now in the wrong band, with households in the North and Midlands more likely to be in too high a band and households in London and the South East more likely to be in too low a band for their property’s current value.
The Commons Housing, Communities and Local Government Committee concluded in a 2025 report that the current system is “regressive and unfair” and recommended that the government should "begin the process of overhauling or replacing council tax". The Institute for Fiscal Studies similarly recommended in 2020 that council tax should be "revalued and reformed"
Meanwhile, critics argue that stamp duty makes it more difficult for first-time buyers to afford a home and disincentivises existing homeowners from moving. The 2011 Mirrlees Review, chaired by economist James Mirrlees, found that this can lead to inflexibility in labour markets where stamp duty makes people less willing to relocate for work. The review also argued that stamp duty is inefficient and that there is “no good economic argument” for taxing homes more because they have been sold more often.
The founder of the campaign group Fairer Share, Andrew Dixon, wrote in Tax Journal in 2025 (PDF) that:
Stamp duty is one of the UK’s most distortionary taxes, discouraging mobility and penalising those who need to move. Council tax, meanwhile, is regressive, outdated, and still based on 1991 property valuations. […] What is needed is a wholesale rebalancing: a shift away from transaction-based and regressive band-based property taxes towards a proportional property tax levied annually on up-to-date market values.
Fairer Share has been campaigning for a “proportional property tax” to replace both council tax and stamp duty. This would be an annual tax, paid by the owner of a property each year based on a percentage of its value. Fairer Share proposes that owners pay 0.48% of their properties’ value in tax every year, with properties revalued annually and the value of a property taken as its average market value over the previous three years. Similar calls for a proportional property tax have been made by the thinktanks Institute for Public Policy Research in a 2021 report, Onward in a 2024 report, CenTax in a 2025 report, the Centre for London in a 2026 report, and the Resolution Foundation in a 2026 report.
Further informationCommons Library research briefing, Local government taxation
Commons Library research briefing, High Value Council Tax Surcharge (HVCTS)
Commons Library research briefing, Stamp duty land tax: Current situation and developments since 2020