Courts and Tribunals Bill: HL Bill 57 of 2026–27
The Courts and Tribunals Bill would introduce various reforms to courts and tribunals in England and Wales. The government said the measures would help reduce the court delays and improve efficiency, however proposals affecting jury trials, magistrates’ courts and appeal rights have proved controversial during the bill’s passage through the House of Commons. Its second reading in the House of Lords is due to take place on 27 October 2026.
Approximate read time: 35 minutes
The Courts and Tribunals Bill forms part of the government’s response to record levels of open cases in the criminal courts of England and Wales. The bill includes provisions based on recommendations made by Lord Leveson’s independent review of the criminal courts and the Law Commission’s review on the use of evidence in sexual offence prosecutions. However, there are differences. The government has argued a combination of investment, modernisation and structural reform is needed to reduce delays and improve the efficiency of the justice system.
The bill would change how criminal cases are allocated and managed between the magistrates’ courts and the crown court. Provisions would include removing an adult defendant’s right to elect for a crown court trial in either-way cases, extending magistrates’ court sentencing powers, introducing judge-only trials for certain complex and lengthy cases, and replacing the automatic right of appeal from the magistrates’ court to the crown court with a permission-based system. The bill would also reform evidence and procedure in sexual offence prosecutions, repeal the presumption of parental involvement in the Children Act 1989, change court and tribunal leadership arrangements, and make other technical reforms.
The bill was amended during its passage through the House of Commons, with only government amendments agreed to. This included the removal of a provision that would have established a crown court bench division for certain either-way offences to be heard by a judge alone, without a jury. The House of Commons Justice Committee and several justice sector stakeholders have questioned the impact of some reforms on fairness, access to justice and magistrates’ court capacity.