Contributions
1,409 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDProperty TaxesMy hon. Friend is absolutely right. I have already shared with the House the classic example of the number of people who have left this country because of a punitive tax regime…03 Sept 2025HANSARDProperty TaxesIf the right hon. Lady wants to make the rules, she should live by them. That message will go out to businesses and families up and down the country. There is no way that they can…03 Sept 2025HANSARDProperty TaxesThere is no doubt that under the previous Government there was a need to support the economy. That involved the expenditure of £400 billion, not least on the furlough scheme. I do…03 Sept 2025HANSARDTaxesMy right hon. Friend is absolutely right. When it comes to criticising this Government, it is always confusing whether to address those on the Front Bench or on the Back Benches,…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesI am not sure that I fully understood the point, but the hon. Gentleman seems at least to accept that there is a real black hole when it comes to this Government, of at least £6…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesI will momentarily. We would of course have tackled the welfare bill, as we did when we were in office. We made £5 billion-worth of savings, as scored by the Office for Budget…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesI think this debate is actually about the tax policy of this Government. As I have clearly set out— [ Interruption. ] To be fair, there was the small matter of covid, which came…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesMy right hon. Friend is absolutely right. With the increasing Government debt to which this Government are constantly adding, and the higher interest rates for longer for which…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesI would be delighted to talk the hon. Gentleman through that. The preceding Labour Government left this country with a deficit of 10.1%, or £160 billion a year, so clearly we had…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesMy hon. Friend is absolutely right. The reality is that if we tax something, we tend to get less of it. This Government have taxed business, so it is not surprising that the…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesIt would be sensible for the hon. Lady to look at those on her own Front Bench and ask why they take these appalling anti-business decisions. The answer is that hardly any of them…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesI think what the hon. Gentleman said was a gross impertinence, Madam Deputy Speaker. He also referred to you as an absolute “shower”, which is totally unreasonable. I have always…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesMy right hon. Friend is absolutely right, and under his stewardship, things were so much better. As he points out, the Government have resiled from any attempt to control the…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesWell yes, exactly. The Government will look to any floating branch or whatever to cling on to, to try to look a little better than they truly are. We have seen a Government who…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesI beg to move, That this House notes that the Government was elected on the basis of a manifesto commitment not to increase taxes on working people and not to increase National…15 Jul 2025HANSARDTaxesIndeed, my hon. Friend is absolutely right. We need to stand up for everybody—even our toolmakers. Let us be frank: we have had to table this motion today, which seeks to do…15 Jul 2025HANSARDGovernment Performance against Fiscal RulesThe Chancellor said that she would not make any commitments that were not “fully funded and fully costed”, but the Chief Secretary to the Treasury has just said that he now…07 Jul 2025HANSARDGovernment Performance against Fiscal RulesIt certainly is now, Madam Deputy Speaker. If Ministers are to begin putting their house back in order, that must start right now with full transparency and proper answers.07 Jul 2025HANSARDGovernment Performance against Fiscal Rules(Urgent Question): To ask the Chancellor of the Exchequer if she will make a statement on the Government’s performance against the fiscal rules.07 Jul 2025HANSARDGovernment Performance against Fiscal RulesDevon.07 Jul 2025