Contributions
825 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 5) BillMy hon. Friend has questioned the ability of the Act to be enforced. My Select Committee, the Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee, put that question to Lord…03 Apr 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 5) BillI will be as brief as I can. I want to speak against clause 1 stand part. The clause is the heart and strategic intent of the Bill. It is trying to put this House in a position to…03 Apr 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 5) BillYes, and we absolutely know why the Bill is framed in these very vague terms—it is precisely to avoid its falling foul of rules that require a money resolution for a Bill that…03 Apr 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) (No. 5) BillI will press on, if my hon. Friend will allow me. I have addressed the enforcement point, but let me come back to the question of legitimacy. The issue is not just the…03 Apr 2019HANSARD Business RatesI congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for The Cotswolds (Sir Geoffrey Clifton-Brown) on securing this excellent debate. All these welcome measures that the Government introduce…02 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseVery droll. My hon. Friend rather misses the point of my opening remarks that I do not wish to discuss Brexit. I simply point out that he voted for the European Union (Withdrawal)…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI will give way to the hon. Gentleman. I noted that he described the procedure as “Game of Thrones”. That underlines how it is open to ridicule. No doubt he will continue his…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseIt is a question of who imported whose model. Montesquieu actually thought that he was copying the British system when he created a United States constitution that gives the…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI agree with my right hon. Friend. I have some criticism of the way in which the Government have conducted their European policy, but they cannot be held responsible for decisions…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI agree with the right hon. Member for Carshalton and Wallington (Tom Brake) on one point: the present situation has obviously arisen because the Government have lost the…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseThat takes me on to my next point, which is that it seems likely, so long as the Fixed-term Parliaments Act 2011 endures, that minority Governments will continue to be vulnerable…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI say to my right hon. and learned Friend that the problem with the process of indicative votes is that MPs are free to pick and choose whatever policies they like, without any…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the House“Ignored” is the operative word that the right hon. Lady uses. Obviously, it is and should always be the practice of Governments to respect the will of the House as expressed in a…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI am deliberately not going to become involved in that argument, but my hon. Friend knows that I do not believe that the withdrawal agreement delivers Brexit. What policy…01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the Houseindicated assent.01 Apr 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI do not think that that is a secret. I am surprised that the hon. Gentleman has not looked it up. The problem is that last week’s indicative votes have already discredited…01 Apr 2019HANSARDUnited Kingdom’s Withdrawal from the European UnionI am perfectly clear that whatever the public voted for in the referendum, or at the last general election, nobody had a clue that they would be voting for a withdrawal agreement…29 Mar 2019HANSARDEU Exit Day AmendmentI am going to press on. This House has now embarked upon an unprincipled constitutional experiment. The Public Administration and Constitutional Affairs Committee, which I chair,…27 Mar 2019HANSARDEU Exit Day AmendmentI agree with my hon. Friend. I will vote against these regulations, and let me say something about the mess that we are now in. I can fairly claim to be one of the minority in…27 Mar 2019HANSARDEU Exit Day AmendmentThis Executive decision was approved by a Minister without proper reference to Parliament, bringing back to this House not just international law but law that is binding in our…27 Mar 2019