Contributions
771 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)In that case I will deal with amendments 30 to 32 once I have addressed amendments 29 and 61, because they all touch on similar issues in relation to clause 4. Much has been said…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)My hon. Friend is right. Flexibility is not a weaking of the safeguards; it is what actually allows the statutory test in clause 4 to operate properly and in appropriate…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)An important point was discussed in earlier exchanges with the hon. Member for Isle of Wight East. While I absolutely accept that marginalised communities experience lower…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)Finally, let me address amendment 46. As Members will get sick of hearing me say, the courts are facing an unprecedented challenge. Although relatively few in number, cases…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)Forgive me, Ms Butler, is it possible that I have not addressed the amendment tabled by the hon. Member for Bexhill and Battle?21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)I thank the shadow Minister for tabling amendment 51. I will first set out the rationale for clause 4 and schedule 1 and then address the amendment. Clause 4 and schedule 1 will…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)My understanding of the time saving—we measure it in the context of Crown court sitting days—is that we are looking at around 500 sitting days, which no one is suggesting is a…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)On a point of order, Ms Jardine. I ask for your guidance. We hear the rehearsal of a number of the same arguments that we have heard again and again over a long period. Everyone…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)We consider it to be set out in clause 4 as drafted. It is sufficiently flexible and will no doubt be subjected to interpretation. We think that, as drafted—with all the carefully…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Eighth sitting)I refer the hon. Gentleman to pages 243 and 245 of the independent review. If we want to come back on the detail, we can, but I am going to make progress. I have dealt with…21 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)The premise of not just these amendments, but amendments that we have already debated, is that other tiers of the system, whether that be the magistrates court or the proposed…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)I do not accept the premise or assumption that everybody has a positive experience of the criminal justice system when they participate in a jury. As the Minister for Courts, I do…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)It is a good question and one that we touched on in our earlier debate in the context of clause 1, where we were discussing the proposal to remove the defendant’s right to insist…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)I do not want to labour the analogy—forgive the pun—but in many senses, we do allow that. Under this system and the reformed system, we preserve the right of the defendant to…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)I think there is some consensus here. We are all extolling the virtues of our system. As the Minister with responsibility not just for courts, but for legal services more…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)The hon. Member asks a typically great question. We did think about it. I am well aware that the right to elect exists, once a defendant is in the superior court in Canada. We…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)I am rejecting the addition of any other carve-outs or exceptions beyond the test of seriousness that we lay down in these measures, which is dictated by the likely sentence, the…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)We do think this is the right balance, which is why we brought it forward. It is the test that was recommended to us by the independent review and we think it is a considered,…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)I am going to make a little progress—16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)I have to make progress. Expanding the test for eligibility beyond seriousness would dilute the focus and risk undermining both the clarity of the allocation framework and the…16 Apr 2026