Contributions
771 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)The hon. Member started with a long digression into trial by ordeal. I hope this Committee will not become a trial by ordeal, but I find the brass neck approach to this from the…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)I have visited lots and lots of courts.14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)While I am very proud of our legal system, I do not necessarily take the view that ours is best and we cannot learn from other systems. Indeed, some of the places that we have…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I appreciate the complexity. We are slightly in the realm of the hypothetical. To be absolutely clear, the purpose of clause 2 is to align the uncommenced written plea and…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)The hon. Lady will have seen that with the presentation of the Bill, as is right and appropriate, a suite of documents and material was made available to Members of this House and…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)I will give way to my hon. Friend.14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)I will just conclude this point. The central insight of the independent review of the criminal courts, in direct answer to the hon. Member for Reigate, borne out by the modelling,…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)I will not take any more interventions; I want to make progress. The point is that we are already beginning to see the investment aspect of this. The second pillar of how we…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)The hon. Member is right. Where currently a defendant charged with a triable either-way offence has the ability to choose trial by jury in the Crown court, even in a scenario in…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)For those watching on TV—which is probably my mum—I will be absolutely clear: the Government are not abolishing jury trials. The Government are preserving jury trials for the most…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)I am not sure who to give way to, but I will give way first to the hon. Lady—I will try to be as fair as I can.14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I have to make a little progress. Let me turn to the detail of clause 1. Part of its function is to ensure consistency across the statute book. To ensure consistency in that way,…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)No, I will not accept that it is inferior. I maintain the position that it is proportionate to the severity of the cases currently dealt with in the magistrates court. When asked…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)No, it has a total air of unreality. If we look at the current system, I think we all agree that it is not working for any participant in the system. It cannot be when there is a…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)The clause sits alongside clause 1 and ensures that the new allocation framework will operate coherently following the removal of the right to elect. It deals specifically with…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)We know that people would rather be in the Crown court because, when they have a right to elect, some opt for that. I have acknowledged that fact, but this is not a debating…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I think the shadow Minister misunderstands me. I am not critiquing our jury trials which, as I have said, are a cornerstone of British justice. I am trying to understand why he…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)Does the shadow Minister accept, though, that the legislation as drafted contains a number of guardrails? They include the provision of reasons that will need to be given by a…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Third sitting)Of course that is right. No one is talking about the abolition of jury trials. We have said, and I will say repeatedly, that juries are a cornerstone of the British legal system…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)We do not necessarily accept that that is why. There may be all sorts of reasons, which need to be unpacked, and that is the kind of thing I hope will be enriched by a statutory…14 Apr 2026