Contributions
1,196 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)It is not the same thing. I asked him, in his role as a UK Government Minister, to seek an assurance from Scottish Government Ministers that the retrospective collection of funds…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)Of course.29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)The Minister has been clear in outlining how the clause relates to the previous clauses, and how he wants to overwhelmingly reform the electricity system. I do not see the clause…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)I beg to move amendment 80, in clause 14, page 18, line 36, after “application.” insert— “(4) Any fees received by the Scottish Ministers under sub-paragraph (2)(d) may only be…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)I am not trying to be difficult with the Minister at all—I know it seems that I am, but I am not. He said that he has not had those conversations but he now will, and that is…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)I will confine myself to clause 17. The Minister has often said that he does not want to direct Scottish Government Ministers on a devolved issue. That is perfectly reasonable.…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)I do not intend to speak for long. I am grateful to the Minister for repeatedly taking interventions, but I think he is in a slight pickle on this one. On a number of occasions he…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)I thank the Minister for his answer. He will forgive me for intervening again; it will mean that I speak less later. In outline, has he started any engagement with Scottish…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)I would like to move new clauses 53 and 54, but I would like to hear what the Minister has to say about them first.29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)Has the Minister identified or outlined any potential total income that will come out of this measure? I know that it is not a certain process and that it is not certain how many…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)My contribution will be very short, because the Opposition agree with what the Minister said. It seems perfectly reasonable to amend section 36D of the Electricity Act 1989, which…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)We are dancing on the head of a pin here. I know that the Minister has no power to do that and does not want to have such a power, but how can he, as a UK Government Minister,…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)The Minister keeps saying “reserved”. That is fine, but we have a Secretary of State for Scotland, accountable to a UK Parliament, who represents Scottish constituencies. There is…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Third sitting)The Minister will be pleased to know that I will not be making a very long speech. I will briefly comment on some of the clauses before the Committee, and elaborate on some of the…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)Thank you. I must apologise, Mr Twigg; this is the first time I have been a shadow Minister on a Bill Committee and I am a bit rusty, but I am learning very quickly. I thank the…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Fourth sitting)Do I move the new clauses now?29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Third sitting)If it suits you.29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Third sitting)I apologise for interrupting the Minister mid-flow, but if the utopian vision that he has outlined is the case—if a Select Committee comes to them within the right amount of time…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Third sitting)I understand that, but the fact of the matter is that the Secretary of State will no longer be required, under the Bill, to respond to feedback from Parliament. That is what the…29 Apr 2025HANSARDPlanning and Infrastructure Bill (Third sitting)I will adhere to your guidance and orders on this Committee, Mrs Hobhouse. I intend to speak to clause 2 first, and then I will address amendment 8, tabled by the hon. Member for…29 Apr 2025