Contributions
1,196 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)I apologise for interrupting the Minister. I understand what she is saying, but we have seen a contradiction from the Government on Second Reading as well as in Committee. Is the…16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)I do not want the hon. Lady to look so disheartened, because I am about to agree with her. She looked horrified that I was intervening on her. The hon. Lady is absolutely right…16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)Will the hon. Lady give way?16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)I rise to speak to new clause 19 in the name of the hon. Member for Brighton Pavilion. I wholly respect the reasons why she tabled it. However, I intend to speak against it,…16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)I will—that is called an election. That is my point. I understand that the hon. Lady comes at this from a genuine position—I hope she accepts that I do, too—but the accountability…16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)The suggestion fills me with horror—I am open in saying that it fills me with utter dread. The electoral process is the point. The hackles on my neck stand up when the words…16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)I think that most campaigning groups are filled with people who are utterly enthralled and want to achieve the outcomes of that group. It is a bit of a generalisation to say that…16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)Subsection (6) of the new clause’s proposed new sections clearly states the words I quoted, which include: “The mayor must…take into account”. Therefore, what the hon. Lady has…16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fifth sitting)Correct me if I am wrong—it may be very rare, but sometimes I am—but earlier, the hon. Member for North West Cambridgeshire asked the Minister for assurance regarding the ability…16 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Third sitting)I agree. I have had many a night out in Brighton, and I know that it is a very vibrant city. If it is good enough for Brighton to be named within that county, I do not see why the…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Third sitting)The Minister says that it is not the Government who are making sure that it happens. I accept that. However, having been in her position for only a short time—that is not her…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fourth sitting)Yes. I thank the Minister for involuntarily giving way to me—Sir John, your rule as Chair is a very happy time for me. The Minister may now think I am being facetious, but I…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fourth sitting)I am not sure that I can beat the excellent oratory of my hon. Friend the shadow Minister, but I want to add some context in my own style on why this clause is a bit of a…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fourth sitting)My intervention will be very brief. I am slightly burnt by my experience on the Planning and Infrastructure Bill Committee, where the Minister constantly said that they would…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fourth sitting)On a point of order, Sir John. Forgive me, I may be ignorant on this, but on the selection list I do not see amendment 361 in the running order. If you could give me some…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fourth sitting)I stand corrected, thank you.14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Fourth sitting)I thank the hon. Lady for giving way at what I think was the end of her speech. I just wondered whether she or her party had done any analysis of the extra cost that her amendment…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Third sitting)There is a risk here that we are conflating what is actually happening on the ground. The Minister is absolutely right, and no one can argue that this Government have not been…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Third sitting)The Minister should be very careful about attributing motives to myself that are not there. I am very supportive of the fact that Hampshire and the Solent and will have a mayor.…14 Oct 2025HANSARDEnglish Devolution and Community Empowerment Bill (Third sitting)I have great sympathy with the point that the hon. Lady is making. Would she agree that town and parish councils are already being asked to take on more services? We are seeing…14 Oct 2025