Contributions
1,134 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)I take no umbrage at all at what the Minister said about Tuesday—Her late Majesty herself famously said that recollections may vary. I think the point has been made. Could he give…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)On a point of order, Mr Betts. If I could record for posterity that neither of the two Liberal Democrats assigned to the Committee are here at the moment. In fairness, one has a…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)During the public evidence session, several of our witnesses—including those from the three service families federations—raised the question of special educational needs provision…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)I am trying to wind up, but I will give way if the hon. Gentleman wishes to make a point. This is an important topic.12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)I am grateful to the hon. Lady. She will know, not least from her service on that important Committee, of what is called the statutory override. In a nutshell, local authorities…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)The hon. Gentleman makes a good point. I do not have the NAO report in front of me, and that is my fault—forgive me—but from memory, it made the point that this was a nationwide…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)I am grateful to the Minister for what he has said; it is very gracious of him. I do not think it is to betray a confidence to say that he and I have threatened to sit down and…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)He has nothing to fear!12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)The Minister mentioned the devolved Administrations point, and that is encouraging. I gave an example of someone who moved from Tidworth garrison to Catterick garrison. Is it now…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship this morning, Mr Efford. I will make a brief contribution to say that we take it as axiomatic that the Armed Forces Commissioner…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Fourth sitting)In a moment. My hon. Friend the Member for Spelthorne is a former commanding officer of the Scots Guards, and he knows the challenge that all commanding officers face in retaining…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)I beg to move amendment 8, in clause 1, page 2, line 2, at end insert— “(5A) The Commissioner shall operate independently from – (a) the Ministry of Defence; (b) the armed forces;…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)The Minister mentions Ajax. I did not, but as he did, we will read that into the record. There were times when the Defence Committee would have dearly loved that power. Had we had…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)I welcome the Minister’s welcome for the amendment. I hope the Committee is doing the right thing here. We tabled it because the issue cropped up a lot in the public evidence…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)Okay, thank you. We live in an increasingly litigious world, including the wider prevalence of so-called lawfare issues on the modern battlefield. Therefore it seems important to…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)I think the amendment speaks for itself. I seem to recall that on Tuesday the Minister laid out a timeframe for the establishment of the commissioner and their office; from…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)The Minister has summarised the clause very well. We understand the intent of the Bill. We said on Second Reading that we would be a critical friend to it, and hopefully that will…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)I declare an interest: I served on the Defence Committee for about seven years. Over the years, there has been a debate about the extent to which the Defence Committee and other…12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)If it is about Ajax, gladly.12 Dec 2024HANSARDArmed Forces Commissioner Bill (Third sitting)They are not directly comparable, but as I was coming on to say, the American Committees have a much stronger power over appointments. To illustrate my point, some debates in the…12 Dec 2024