Contributions
2,673 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Fifth sitting)To clarify, the amendments do not seek to make those grounds discretionary in any case. We accept that they are mandatory. We believe that the amendments would allow those…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Fifth sitting)I am disappointed by the Minister’s response. I welcome the clarification he gave. The amendments would introduce a limited amount of discretion. We would argue that they do not…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)I beg to move amendment 136, in clause 3, page 3, leave out lines 21 and 22 and insert— “1, 1A, 1B, 2, 2ZA, 2ZB, 6, 6A four months beginning with the date of service of the notice…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)Clause 3, as we have discussed, amends the grounds for possession in schedule 2 to the Housing Act 1988. Once section 21 has finally been removed from that Act through the…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)I am glad that the hon. Gentleman has decided to contribute, because he has a huge amount of experience in this area. I hope that I was as clear as possible when making the case…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)Paragraph 20 of schedule 1 amends ground 7 in schedule 2 to the Housing Act 1988. Ground 7 requires a court to award possession if a tenancy has been passed to someone by will or…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)Those were two very helpful explanations of why these amendments are necessary. On that basis, I beg to ask leave to withdraw the amendment. Amendment, by leave, withdrawn .21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)I beg to move amendment 137, in clause 3, page 3, line 32, at end insert— “(4) The Secretary of State must lay before Parliament a review of the changes to grounds for possession…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)If I have understood the Minister correctly, he has made a commitment to go away and think further about this. As it stands, is there anything in the Bill that would protect…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)I say two things to the Minister. First, the minimum notice periods are from the date of service of the notice. I take the point about court reform, but this is at the point of…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)I will not withdraw the amendment; I am going to press it to a vote because, again, I do not think the Government have got the balance right. I do not think that two months’…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)That is a reasonable point. Landlords will adapt to the system. They will have it in mind that they must automatically make an offer to the sitting tenant. If they determine that…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)That is some progress. If we have a commitment from the Minister that we will get detailed guidance that landlords need to submit—21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)We are disappointed with the Minister’s response, for the following reasons. We will, no doubt, hear ad nauseam about the Government’s intention and the obvious need, with which…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)That is welcome, but I think the concern is still there, because what does the guidance say? We do not know. What proof does it ask for? We have a clear set of evidential…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Sixth sitting)I will happily give way to the Minister again if he can say how the judge would prove an intent to sell or occupy the property without evidential requirements. The judge does not…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Fifth sitting)I think the Minister has to be very careful on that point. It depends on what the enforcement action is, and on the degree to which the landlord is at fault. The enforcement…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Fifth sitting)I have been on enough Bill Committees to know that the Minister has been sent out with explicit instructions to resist amendments—we all understand that—but the Government will…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Fifth sitting)I beg to move amendment 149, in clause 3, page 2, line 32, at end insert— “(aa) After subsection (5) insert— ‘(5ZA) The court shall not make an order for possession under Ground…21 Nov 2023HANSARDRenters (Reform) Bill (Fifth sitting)It is a real pleasure to begin our line-by-line consideration with you in the Chair, Mr Gray. It is a genuine privilege to serve on a Committee with such evident expertise in the…21 Nov 2023