Contributions
927 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q With regards to the article 8 changes, can you give us one concrete example of a category of case where someone could successfully resist removal today on article 8 grounds, but…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q We do not know how many more removals we are expecting as a result, and we do not know how much faster it is going to go. What would you see as the benchmark for measuring…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q From your experience of running Border Force, what actually deters an illegal channel crossing? Will anything in the Bill materially strengthen that deterrent? Tony Smith: I…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q What impact do you expect the financial penalties for companies that fail to comply with the reporting requirements to have on company compliance? Dr Buttle: As I say, we have…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q What is the single biggest border control measure missing from the Bill? Tony Smith: It is more what it does not do, which is exclude people coming from safe third countries,…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q There has been much discussion about the challenge posed by the article 8 issue, but can you give me an example of a category of case that today might be frustrated by article 8…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (First sitting)Q From your operational experience, what is the single biggest thing missing from the Bill that would help the NCA to tackle the crime gangs behind the crossings? Has the NCA…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q Minister, the independent Regulatory Policy Committee has rated the Government’s impact assessment of the Bill as not fit for purpose. It says: “Little of the appraisal is…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q Are there any particular specifics on how you would improve the measures that have been put forward? Dr Buttle: At CCLA we have been advocating, in addition to reporting…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q As it stands, do you believe that the modern slavery supply chain provisions in the Bill will identify more victims and perpetrators, or is there a risk that they will create…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (First sitting)Q What is the biggest thing missing from the Bill in helping you to tackle the crime gangs? Did you ask the Government for any specific things that have not come to be? Helen…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (First sitting)Q To get the result that we want—tackling that abuse—what else should the Home Office be doing in that space? If this is not a solution, what would you put forward as an…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q 56 Dr Sumption, looking at the evidence rather than at the Government’s intentions, which provisions in the Bill are likely to reduce arrivals or increase removals, and which…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (First sitting)Q Do you believe that someone who deliberately enters the UK illegally from a safe country should face a different immigration consequence from someone who enters using a legal…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (First sitting)Q If you think that the outcome of entering illegally should be the same as the outcome of entering legally, is there any other deterrent in that space? If the immigration…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q The sole test for the Bill is whether it will reduce illegal arrivals and increase removals. What is the single biggest amendment you would put forward to make that difference?…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (First sitting)Q Is there a particular feature that you would have liked to see in the Bill to aid you in that objective? Helen Rance: No.15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q Is there any evidence that expanding safe and legal routes would reduce the number of small boat crossings, rather than simply increase the overall number of people coming to…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q How many people are currently in the UK who have exhausted their appeal rights and have no lawful right to remain, and what is the single biggest barrier preventing immigration…15 Sept 2026HANSARDImmigration and Asylum Bill (Second sitting)Q Do you have a rough proportion? Anna Turley: I would not want to give incorrect figures. If it is okay, I will reply to the Committee in writing with that information. Dan…15 Sept 2026