Contributions
524 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q Thank you. I am particularly interested to hear from the two of you, because one of the interesting things about this Bill is that we have had a lot of lobbying from the…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q There was an interesting intervention yesterday from the Reform party about local government pensions. I know that is not necessarily part of what we are talking about now, but…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)That is very helpful, thank you. I am very conscious that other Members will almost certainly have questions, but I must say that I entirely agree with you that a sum of money set…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q Could you expand a little on the technicalities of how that would work? Obviously, the trustees are there to represent the members, but they are merely a small board of…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q I have one final question. Various clauses look at the asset manager and the trustees effectively marking their own homework on this. There are consequences of an intermediate…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q Very quickly, if you get an intermediate rating, is it published? Tim Fassam: Your value for money rating will be published.02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q You raise a very interesting point. Members could come up with an idea. For example, you mentioned ESG, which is a fine thing—I would not disagree with that—but sometimes it…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q So you could run into the same problems that we saw recently where the Financial Ombudsman Service was publishing who has been under investigation, which caused problems. That…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q The Bill provides for surplus extraction from funds. Do you see that as a good or a bad thing? Morten Nilsson: I see it as a good thing. I think it will change the pension…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q My last question—Chris, leap in at any point if you feel you have an answer—is about paying out surpluses, either to local government or defined benefit pension schemes. Lots of…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q For defined-benefit pension funds? Morten Nilsson: Yes.02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q Do you feel the Bill covers that management? Jack Jones: I think it puts a lot of responsibility on trustees to make that assessment. I think it is fair enough to set out the…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)If I remember rightly, the Bill allows for the detail to come in afterwards, so we will have a bit of work to do when this is all over. Thank you very much.02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q One of the questions around that is what drives a removal. We heard from previous witnesses that if a host employer puts in more money than is necessary, it seems perfectly…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q Also, similarly on the equity point: with defined benefit pension schemes, as I mentioned a bit earlier, if you have a deficit, that then appears on the balance sheet. The…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q Michelle, you run the compensation scheme. Do you see any risk in surplus extraction? I know that by definition, it is surplus and therefore you should be able to take it out,…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q Do you stress test the pensions industry in the same way as the Bank of England stress tests the banking system? Michelle Osterma n n: Yes—it is very similar.02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q Thank you very much for coming along to give evidence this morning. I want to start with a general question: what do you see as the risks associated with surplus extraction? As…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)And you war game it? Michelle Osterma n n: Yes. The biggest variable that we have a hard time predicting in those scenarios is the likelihood of this being used and the manner in…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q I must ask a question that is perhaps a self beat-up, if you like. There was a disastrous mini-Budget a few years ago under a different Prime Minister—of course, at the time, we…02 Sept 2025