Contributions
524 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q Minister, thank you for coming to give evidence—we have a long few weeks together. I will start with the evidence we heard from the Deprived Pensioners Association and the…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q Yes, but there is a serious issue here, which is that you are now the Minister for Pensions and in a position to be able to do something about this. We can look back on the last…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q When you talk about the wider public finance implications, I completely get it; we understand that there is a lot of debt and all the rest of it. The bit I am struggling with is…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q I move on to value for money, something which, in the broadest sense, everybody seems to agree is a good thing, but I want to pick up on a couple of points. In the evidence…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q I have one very last question, if I may, going back to the mandation piece and the evidence that we heard from Helen Forrest Hall. The mandation piece is a reserved power, with…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)So do I.02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Thank you very much.02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q Thank you very much for coming to give evidence. It can be a little intimidating, even for us, to see so many Government Back Benchers sitting across the table. I will start…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q To summarise, you are saying that the general direction of the policy, which is to get more investment into the UK and therefore more infrastructure, is not in itself a bad…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q 64 Thank you for coming to this afternoon’s session. Councillor Phillips, I will start with you on the big argument about mandation. Obviously, these are reserved powers, which…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q For trustees, the arrangement will be slightly different if it goes into a big pool, but to what extent do you think local authorities, if they are going to see mandation, would…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q It is difficult. You raised the point about geographical location and that a mayoral authority could have three different funds within it. More important, Cornwall county…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q So the key point is that every single investment must be done on a benefit analysis rather than a social good analysis? Councillor Phillips: If you do not do that, I do not know…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q Ironically, I met some annuity providers who are enthusiastic to invest in equities, but they told me that they are being prevented from doing so. For example, an investment in…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q There is potential for surpluses to be paid back into the community. Is that not a good alternative for that type of more social investment as opposed to non-commercial…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q That is very helpful. Robert, would you like to add anything? Robert McInroy: Yes, on the last point about surpluses. I am a fund actuary. We are working through the 2025…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q I have one final question. The key point, from the point of view of your members and the local government pension scheme, is that the interest of the members should not be…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q Would you suggest a higher hurdle for valuations in terms of surplus distribution? Robert McInroy: That has been discussed on a fund-by-fund basis—whether the funding target…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (Second sitting)Q Would you support that? Robert McInroy: I support looking at the range of options, which includes reducing employer contributions and flexing investment strategy, including for…02 Sept 2025HANSARDPension Schemes Bill (First sitting)Q Thank you very much for coming to give evidence. Can I get straight into a detailed question regarding the repayment of surpluses, starting with the local government pension…02 Sept 2025