Contributions
946 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI will come in a moment to the word “exceptional” as I think that was the point made by the noble Lord, Lord German. I have been a little diverted on the way, but we will get…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI hear the words, “higher bar”. I do not disagree that “exceptional circumstances” is a stricter test. There is case law on that, although the name of the case has slipped my…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillMy Lords, these amendments seek to ensure that the courts depart from imposing a minimum sentence, to use the words of the amendment, only where it would be “contrary to the…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillMy Lords, this is obviously an important set of amendments. I thank all those who spoke on the arguments put forward. We agree across the Committee that sexual violence is a…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillMy Lords, the amendments all refer to the unduly lenient sentence scheme, which is set out in Sections 35 and 36 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988. It allows anyone to ask for…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillMy Lords, this is a drafting amendment to Clause 107. Its purpose, as I hope has been explained, is to prevent a prisoner who is serving a sentence for an offence which, at the…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillMy Lords, we have had a very interesting debate. The last few speeches have highlighted the problems with the approach that I was going to set out. In short, where we end up on…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI do not want to give an incorrect answer to the noble Lord. I know that there are different codes of practice and different sets of procedures in various parts of the Bill. Can I…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI have said that we will publish the principles which underpin the Secretary of State’s decision. The other point that I make in this regard, which goes to the adequacy of reasons…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI am certainly not critical of any particular sentence passed in any particular case. What I do think the figures show is that we need a test that more clearly balances the…10 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI am afraid that, with respect, the noble Baroness is wrong on both points. There are provisions in the Bill which change the law considerably; there are quite a few in this area.…08 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI am certainly aware of the differences between dangerous driving and careless driving. Dangerous driving is reserved for those instances of driving which fall “far below” the…08 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillThe noble Baroness and I are sitting on opposite sides of the House. If I was driving, I would normally open the door with my right hand, so I was turning round to open it. I…08 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI will be very careful here because the law in this area is really complex. I was going to say this later but will preface it now. I am very happy to have a discussion on these…08 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillTo be clear, the only reason I made that point is because I have a very long answer—I am happy to read it—explaining the different ways particular police forces have responded to…08 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillAbsolutely. Let me deal with the out of court disposals themselves. I hope I have answered that point. There will, we hope, be a greater consistency of approach, but there will be…08 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillI will come to that point. I will try to answer that question, but if I do not, I know the noble and learned Lord will remind me. However, I think I will come to it. I was just…08 Nov 2021HANSARDPolice, Crime, Sentencing and Courts BillMy Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, and others for speaking to these amendments. This group considers the sentencing of road traffic offences, and I propose…08 Nov 2021