Contributions
1,500 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)I beg to move amendment 154, in schedule 1, page 122, line 11, leave out sub-paragraph (3). This amendment prevents the Government from giving directions to the interim chief…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)Well, yes is the answer. We are trying to bind those Committees to some extent to do the right thing, as far as those appointments are concerned. The hon. Gentleman who has…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)Yes, indeed—Secretaries of State come and go, just as Presidents of the USA come and go. Nevertheless, while they are there, Presidents can appoint justices of the Supreme Court…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)Mr Gray, if I gave that impression then I am sorry, but I thought I was speaking to sub-paragraph (3) of paragraph 4, which is that the chief executive “must act in accordance…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)The hon. Member is quite right to draw attention to good parliamentary mechanisms. I do not want us to be diverted into a long discussion about the Executive and the unwritten UK…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)As it happens, yes. However, again, we are in “as it happens” territory, which we seem to be in rather a lot this afternoon. As it happens, yes, that appears to be working quite…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)I am not suggesting that anything is other than that, and I am not suggesting that the Select Committees are anything other than pleased with what they have undertaken to do and…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)A very good one, if I may say, but nevertheless a speech. You are right, Mr Gray. The point the hon. Gentleman was making is that a process of scrutiny will, in this instance, be…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)The Minister has yet again provided us with a description of things that happen, as opposed to what ought to happen as far as this House is concerned. On the second category of…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)The hon. Member has put his finger exactly on the problem, because according to this piece of legislation, in practice, they do not. There is no requirement to do that in the…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)That is indeed a concern. We have raised, and will repeatedly raise, the difference between the Bill’s aspirations and many of the practicalities. The difference between the…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)I beg to ask leave to withdraw the amendment. Amendment, by leave, withdrawn. Clause 20 ordered to stand part of the Bill . Clause 21 ordered to stand part of the Bill. Schedule 1…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)I can understand the hon. Member indicating that this may be semantics, and indeed, it may be. I was attempting to elucidate the question of whether our being an original…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)That is true, but nevertheless there is the question of the extent to which that commitment itself is a freestanding commitment or additional, via EU retained law. I think the…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)Has the Minister thought about the extent to which the Aarhus convention is fully implemented in the UK, either via retained EU law or the existing domestic system? In terms of…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)I appreciate that the Minister has already replied, but I wonder whether she could—03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)The explanatory statement for this particular amendment relates to the question of securing better or further effecting full compliance with the Aarhus convention, which is a…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)I beg to move amendment 95, in clause 20, page 12, line 32, at end insert— “(7) The Secretary of State must— (a) keep under consideration whether there are any steps which they…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)We have the Minister’s explanation of how the word “significant” is to be defined: it is not to be defined, effectively. We also have what I would kindly say is a descriptive,…03 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Ninth sitting)Thank you, Chair. Following your advice, I will wind up on this group of amendments. In so doing, it is conceivable that I might refer to some of the amendments during the course…03 Nov 2020