Contributions
1,500 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I beg to move amendment 5, in clause 30, page 18, line 6, leave out “may” and insert “must” Where the OEP carries out an investigation this amendment seeks to ensure that it is…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)That is an interesting point. This clause does not appear to be able to decide whether the OEP should or should not do something. Having said that it should be a strong,…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)It is not a question of undermining the integrity of the OEP at all. As the hon. Gentleman says, it does not exist yet, although bits of it are gradually coming into existence and…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)There are a number of existing laws, protocols and arrangements for all public bodies that give them, in certain circumstances, discretion not to do certain things, such as in…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I regret to say that I have not yet been elevated to that position.05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)Something that we have been trying to point out fairly consistently as we have gone through the Bill is the use of “may” and “must”, and we will come shortly to another one of…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I beg to move amendment 6, in clause 32, page 18, line 40, leave out “may” and insert “must”. Where the OEP has reasonable grounds for suspecting a serious break of environmental…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I wonder whether the Minister’s speaking note was written before the Government tabled the next amendment that we will debate, because his reply is one that I might well have…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)Yet again, we may be defending the Bill from its detractors, who happen, on this occasion, to be in the Government. The traffic is not always one way. The substantial problem of…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I beg to move amendment 118, in clause 33, page 19, line 39, at end insert— “(2A) A decision notice may also direct the public authority to rectify the failure to comply with…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I thank the Minister for that response. Our suggestion that the OEP ought to have a more serious power has to some extent been answered with reassurance by the Minister. However,…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)This is a substantial group of amendments that all have the same effect—to transfer proceedings in a variety of different areas from the upper tribunal to the High Court. I…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)With respect, independence has nothing to do with an authority not doing what it should do or just deciding that it cannot be bothered to do something or other. That is not…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)Indeed, my hon. Friend makes the point about specialist environmental expertise in a far better way than the Government did to the EFRA Committee. Among other things, the upper…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Tenth sitting)I beg to move amendment 157, in schedule 1, page 124, line 40, at end insert— “12A (1) At the start of each five-year period, the Secretary of State must publish and lay before…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Tenth sitting)I beg to move amendment 105, in clause 22, page 13, line 18, at end insert— ‘(5A) The Energy Act 2013 is amended in accordance with subsections (5B) and (5C). (5B) In section…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I beg to move amendment 4, in clause 27, page 16, line 16, leave out “may, if the Minister sees fit,” and insert “must”. At first sight, this amendment looks as if it is just…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I am not entirely sure that what the Minister has said this afternoon clarifies the matter to the extent that we wanted in our amendment. However, I draw attention to the fact…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I beg to move amendment 99, in clause 26, page 15, line 31, at end insert “(including international environmental law)”. Again, this it is a fairly straightforward amendment. For…05 Nov 2020HANSARDEnvironment Bill (Eleventh sitting)I thank the Minister for that explanation. I am not entirely sure that it completely satisfies our concerns, but under the circumstances we do not wish to press the amendment to a…05 Nov 2020