Contributions
2,393 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDBusiness of the HouseAfter first “Commons” to insert “, and only once current legal proceedings relating to prorogations in the Scottish courts have been concluded”.04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseMy noble friend makes that point extremely well. I think all of us on this side feel very grateful for that and I fully endorse what he has said.04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseIs it not extraordinary that when a noble Baroness stands up and makes a heartfelt and serious contribution, we get guffaws from the tieless mob on the Back Benches?04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseHere is a reversal of roles. I spent about 13 years—I hesitate to say it—drafting the odd amendment for the noble Lord, Lord Strathclyde. Here is the noble Lord, Lord Strathclyde,…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseThe Companion actually says that anybody who is introducing an amendment is entitled to speak for 20 minutes. I was not proposing to speak for as long as that but I have taken a…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseIt is extraordinary that, when one is trying to round something off amicably, some people mutter in that way. The purpose of all the amendments—the noble Baroness on the Front…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI do not normally like to use the H word, but it will be printed in Hansard and I will not be applying for it to be expunged.04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseThe Salisbury doctrine is very important for relations between the two Houses. It allows this House freedom to challenge and dissent on things that are not covered by the…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI very strongly disagree with my noble friend, and I will discuss my heart when he discusses his soul on this matter. The question of Prorogation is not before us now. I will…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseNo, I will not. I will not be sidetracked—04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseMoved by After “House of Commons, that” to insert “an urgent report be requested from the Constitution Committee on the propriety of the use of a guillotine motion, and should…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseDoes the noble and learned Lord not think that the public are entitled to understand what the motivation is? Is he unhappy about the lending of the girdle of honesty by this…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseI have. The noble Lord is a little more fly than I expected. I thought that he might not have read it but I give him credit.04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseIt might help the House if I responded for 30 seconds to the amendment to withdraw the amendment, because I think that the spirit of the House is right on this. I shall not press…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseThen do not impose the guillotine; do not use the closure Motion on this issue. I shall give way to a representative of a party that opposes power.04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseMy Lords, my noble friend may be right, but I do not wish to follow on that point, because I believe that the principle applies to all legislation. In brief response, I pointed…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseThe noble Lord has been a member of many Governments, and year after year has attended ceremonies of Prorogation with the sovereign there. He knows full well that it is a…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseIf I could help my noble friend against a most absurd attack, if I may say so, we have just had a great disquisition from the Front Bench opposite—from the Leader of the…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseIn my judgment, my noble friend’s point is entirely correct. As he noticed, and as I have pointed out to the House before, in both Houses, in Division after Division on measure…04 Sept 2019HANSARDBusiness of the HouseAfter first “Commons” to insert “, and only once any current legal proceedings relating to prorogations in the English courts have been concluded”.04 Sept 2019