Contributions
623 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillIf the role of the court of justice is, as the Minister puts it, a major obstacle because of democratic deficit, as he describes it, can he please explain to the Committee why…07 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillPerhaps I could invite the noble Lord, when he writes to the noble and learned Lord, Lord Judge, to explain why it is appropriate for Ministers to have the power to make…07 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillMy Lords, as we go through this Committee, we are discussing clauses that confound constitutional principle in ever more astonishing ways. I entirely agree with what was just said…07 Nov 2022HANSARDOnline Safety BillCould the noble Lord suggest to business managers that if further time is required for the Bill and is not otherwise available, it would be available if the Government were to…07 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillMy Lords, I draw attention to the suggestion that Clause 20 should not stand part. During these Committee debates, we have addressed a number of extraordinary provisions in the…07 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillMy Lords, when the purpose and the intended effect of a clause are unclear, it sometimes helps to look at the Explanatory Notes to the Bill. These are produced, of course, by the…07 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillIf that is the case, would the Minister be sympathetic to an amendment on Report that puts that in the Bill?07 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillIt is elementary as a matter of diplomacy and of international law that a country is perfectly entitled to reach a new agreement in the circumstances as they then exist. That is…02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillIf the noble Lord’s position is that the EU is acting in bad faith, the United Kingdom, if it takes that view, is perfectly entitled to use the procedures set out in the protocol…02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillAs always, the noble and learned Baroness speaks great sense. I shall address very briefly a point that is not about electricity, although I hope it may spark some general…02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillVery helpful.02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillIt is getting late—we are almost at dinnertime, I hope. The point is about international law. Clause 13 would exclude the jurisdiction of the Court of Justice of the European…02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillThe noble Lord said that the Government take the view that it is inappropriate for the court of justice to retain jurisdiction, but why is it necessary—that is the test in…02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillCould I suggest to the noble Lord, before he sits down, that the real question is not whether the Ministers on the Front Bench would be happy to exercise these powers, but whether…02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillThere are many difficulties with that argument, the first being that there are good-faith negotiations that the United Kingdom is involved in. One cannot assume that they will not…02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillMay I ask the noble Lord two questions? First, should these problems not have been considered by the United Kingdom Government before they signed the protocol? Secondly, is there…02 Nov 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillMy Lords, I am not going to comment on the politics of Northern Ireland—I am a mere lawyer—but the noble Lord, Lord Campbell, raised a particular point on Article 16, and the…31 Oct 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillI completely agree with the noble Lord, particularly in relation to his tribute to the noble and learned Lord, Lord Judge. In his absence—as his junior as it were—I draw this…31 Oct 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillFor my part, and I am sure it is true of others who have spoken in this debate, I am not asking the Government to exercise Article 16 tomorrow. The point is that the availability…25 Oct 2022HANSARDNorthern Ireland Protocol BillOr contributed.25 Oct 2022