Contributions
1,367 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillMy Lords, I would be very happy to get a letter from the Minister.24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillBefore the Minister’s peroration, I just want to check something. He talked about the discovery project and contact with the industry; by that, I assume he was talking about asset…24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillDid the Minister say £500 million?24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillI am sorry to keep coming back, but did the Minister give us the paragraph in the impact assessment that referred to £500 million?24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillCould the Minister clarify: was that paragraph 1(1)?24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillMy Lords, has not that demonstrated the disproportionality of these measures?24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillMy Lords, we have talked about proportionality and disproportionality throughout the debate on this Bill. Is it not extraordinary that that figure is not on the table, given the…24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillThe Minister is saying that that figure is not to be found in this green-rated impact assessment, which most of us find to be completely opaque.24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillI asked about the amount of fraud that the Government plan to detect, on top of the £6.4 billion in welfare overpayments that was detected last year.24 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillI may have missed something, but can I just check that the Minister will deal with the matter of signals, which he mentioned at the beginning of his response? Will he deal with…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillMy Lords, I would of course much prefer Clause 128 not to stand part, but we were just privileged by a master class from the noble Baroness, Lady Sherlock. She talked about these…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillIt is also worth pointing out that the paragraph I quoted follows immediately on that. That is the qualification that I quoted.22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillMy Lords, tracking the provenance of Clause 113 has been a very interesting exercise. If we think that Clause 114 is pretty politically motivated, Clause 113 is likewise. These…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillMy Lords, I am sorry to interrupt the Minister but, throughout these two groups, he has, in a sense, introduced wholly new concepts. We have “test and learn”, “filtering”—which…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillSo what the Minister is saying is that the solicitor, if you like, who is asking you to sign this petition does not have to say, “Do you mind if I use your email address or if we…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillMy Lords, it is all about the relative importance and the weighting. Maybe that is a good illustration of where the Government are not getting their weighting correct for the…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillThe Minister used the expression “when the evidence emerges”, as did the noble Viscount, Lord Camrose, in another context last week. I would have thought that these organisations…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillWill the Minister write and unpack exactly what the balance of opinion was? We are talking about pretty crucial stuff here. It is not always a question just of numbers; it is…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillMy Lords, I do not know how unusual this is, but we are on the same page across both sides of the Committee. First, having signed the amendments by the noble Lord, Lord Lucas, I…22 Apr 2024HANSARDData Protection and Digital Information BillI am not going to carry on much longer. I know that that will be a grave disappointment but it makes the case, I think, that it is high time that the Government did something in…22 Apr 2024