Contributions
764 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDJoint Enterprise: Young Black MenMy Lords, I am unable to agree that this indicates a miscarriage of justice. We do not have precise figures on the number of persons who successfully appealed following the Jogee…19 Oct 2023HANSARDJoint Enterprise: Young Black MenMy Lords, as far as I am aware, the Law Commission is looking at the question of reforming the law on appeal. I am not so sure—I stand to be corrected—that it is looking into…19 Oct 2023HANSARDJoint Enterprise: Young Black MenI thank my noble friend for that question. The national pilot is part of much wider work by the CPS to understand the high number of charges against persons from ethnic…19 Oct 2023HANSARDJoint Enterprise: Young Black MenPrisoners in the position that my noble friend refers to would have been able to consider the Jogee case and appeal if that was the right course or refer their case to the…19 Oct 2023HANSARDJoint Enterprise: Young Black MenMy Lords, as I have just said, I do not accept that the study so far reveals disproportionality. I accept that this is a very sensitive subject, and we must avoid anything that…19 Oct 2023HANSARDJoint Enterprise: Young Black MenMy Lords, if I may respectfully say so, the results so far of the pilot prove nothing of the sort. The pilot showed a high number of black males in joint enterprise cases in the…19 Oct 2023HANSARDJoint Enterprise: Young Black MenMy Lords, joint enterprise case law is primarily a matter for the judiciary. The CPS applies that case law and race plays no part in individual charging decisions. Recognising…19 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, I would need notice of that question. I will write to the noble and learned Baroness with respect to the place of residential places in the criminal justice system.…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, I will respectfully repeat the Statement made yesterday in another place by my right honourable friend the Lord Chancellor: “The first duty of any Government is to keep…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, I will deal as best I can with the points made. Hospital pass or not, the Government have to deal with the situation in which they find themselves. On the question of…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, I am sure the evidence before and the conclusions of the committee will be borne well in mind.17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, I am not in a position today to comment specifically on Berwyn. I had understood that there are many aspects of Berwyn that have been outstandingly successful. I will…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, it is undoubtedly the case that there are many offenders in the criminal justice system who have severe mental health problems. I very much welcome the noble Lord’s…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, there has been some slippage in the prison building programme, mainly as a result of difficulties with planning. As the Lord Chancellor indicated in the Statement, there…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityThe Government very much welcome the contribution that local agencies and other organisations make towards rehabilitation and will continue to take advantage of all the…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, as always, my noble friend makes a powerful point about the importance of families, both in avoiding crime in the first place and in supporting criminals who later…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityI am not in a position to draw any comparison with Germany or any other country. However, I am bound to say that we need to learn as much as we can from the experience of other…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, as your Lordships will understand, I cannot comment on particular cases in which fines for Covid infringements have been levied, nor am I in a position to say that the…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityThe main effort in getting remand numbers down is to do everything possible to accelerate the process in the Crown Court. We have recruited over 1,000 new judges and increased…17 Oct 2023HANSARDPrison CapacityMy Lords, I fully agree that there needs to be close interdepartmental co-operation in dealing with this difficult issue.17 Oct 2023