Contributions
1,430 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (Second sitting)I am pleased to see the list included and the number of things that Ofcom can ask for more information on. I have a specific question about amendment 75. Amendment 75 talks about…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (Second sitting)The in-game chat that children use is overwhelmingly voice chat. Children do not type if they can possibly avoid it. I am sure that that is not the case for all children, but it…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)I beg to move amendment 98, in clause 11, page 10, line 17, at end insert “, and— (c) mitigate the harm to children caused by habit-forming features of the service by…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)That is absolutely the case. We are talking about cats because I chose them to illustrate the situation, but people may look at content about healthy eating, and that moves on to…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)Thank you, Sir Roger. I absolutely agree with the hon. Member for Warrington North. The platform works by stitching things together, so a video could have a bit of somebody else’s…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)The hon. Lady makes an excellent point. This is not about mandating that platforms stop doing these things; it is about ensuring that they take this issue into account and that…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)If platforms do not recognise that they have an issue with habit-forming features, even though we know they have, will Ofcom say to them, “Your risk assessment is insufficient. We…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)I would have preferred it had the Minister been slightly more explicit that habit-forming features are harmful. That would have been slightly more helpful.13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)I thank the Minister. Absolutely—they are not always harmful. With that clarification, I am happy to beg to ask leave to withdraw the amendment. Amendment, by leave, withdrawn.13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)Thank you, Sir Roger. It was helpful to hear the Minister’s clarification of age assurance and age verification, and it was useful for him to put on the record the difference…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)On that specific point, I searched on Twitter for the name—first name and surname—of a politician to see what people had been saying, because I knew that he was in the news. The…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)I am glad that the three amendments are grouped, because they link together nicely. I am concerned that clause 11(4)(d) does not do exactly what the Government intend it to. It…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)Absolutely, I agree, but the problem is with the way the Bill is written. It does not suggest that a platform could stop somebody accessing a certain part of a service. The Bill…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)I think that that is what the clause achieves, rather than the amendments that I have tabled. I recognise that the clause achieves that, and I have no concerns about it. It is…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)That is exactly why users should be able to block private messaging in general. Someone on Twitter can say, “I’m not going to receive a direct message from anybody I don’t…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)I completely agree. The hon. Member put that much better than I could. I was trying to formulate that point in my head, but had not quite got there, so I appreciate her…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)Thank you, Sir Roger; I appreciate the clarification. When I talk about Government amendment 4, I will also talk about clause stand part. I withdraw the amendment.13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)What I am saying is that the clause does not actually allow that middle step. It does not explicitly say that somebody could be stopped from accessing private messaging. The only…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)If someone on a PlayStation wants to play online games, they must sign up to PlayStation Plus—that is how the model works. Once they pay that subscription, they can access online…13 Dec 2022HANSARDONLINE SAFETY BILL (First sitting)I have a concern. The Minister’s phrasing was “to block children’s access”. Surely some of the issues would be around blocking adults’ access, because they are the ones causing…13 Dec 2022