Contributions
1,286 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Third sitting)Q Meeting net zero is a public good, looking at climate mitigation and adaptation. Do you feel the Bill could be stronger on that? My concern is that while in a sector like…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Do you think that, in terms of the consumer side of things, that would be more an issue for the food strategy? I think there will be quite a focus in that on— Sue Davies: It is…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Could we talk about peatlands? You have been very involved in trying to make the case for the restoration of peatlands and their role as a natural climate solution. Do you think…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Fourth sitting)Q We mentioned clause 17 on food security, which is new to this edition of the Bill. Do you think there is scope for an extra provision? It talks about looking at global food…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I am trying to tease this out, because we have heard previous witnesses say that there is concern about the lack of baseline regulation in the Bill and the fact that we no…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Fourth sitting)Is that how it would work? That is the other thing. It is the same as with planting trees or improving soil health; there is a danger that, in a bid to use public money to…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I suppose the Bill is encouraging more humane production methods and so on, and the food strategy is making sure, at the consumer end of things and the marketing end of things,…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Some groups are talking about method of slaughter labelling. Does Which? have a view? Would the consumers you deal with find that useful? Sue Davies: It is not something that we…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Third sitting)Q Where to start? Could you say a bit more about the whole-farm systems approach and the concern that the Bill might lead to farmers cherry-picking some of the public goods, but…13 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (First sitting)Q Do you mean the baseline regulations? Martin Lines: Under the current system we have cross-compliance. With those who choose not to engage in the system, because they want to…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (First sitting)Q As I understand it, at the moment, farmers will get the basic payments for just having the land. If you check cross-compliance and they are not meeting the standards, they will…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (First sitting)Q May I just ask about the climate change angle? The NFU has said that it wants to reach net zero farming by 2040. There is no target in the Bill. My concern is that farmers do…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Second sitting)Q And the climate change thing, possibly. Graeme Willis: Yes, climate change being one of the objectives. It is very important, given we know the level of emissions from upland…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (First sitting)Q Do you think the Bill does enough to encourage the whole-farm approach, or is there a danger that farmers might just pick and choose among the public goods and do some of the…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (First sitting)Q May I return to the regulatory baseline issue I raised with the previous witnesses? The RSPB was involved in the Institute for European Environmental Policy report published…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Second sitting)Q Well, we probably do not have time to go into that. This is probably a question for Graeme, to start with, but others can chip in if they wish. I have two quick questions.…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Second sitting)Q You have farmed game birds that are released into the world to be shot. Jake Fiennes: But a game farmer is not a farmer. He is not a poultry producer either, strangely. Sorry,…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Second sitting)Q I thought that the whole justification for game shooting was that people eventually eat the birds, even though we know that they could not possibly consume as many as were shot.…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Second sitting)Q Did you just say that game should be taken out of the Bill altogether because it is a leisure pastime, not an agricultural pastime? Jake Fiennes: Game is not agriculture. Game…11 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Second sitting)Q This is probably a question specifically for David Goodwin. What role do you see county farms playing, given that the Government and the Minister have in the past expressed…11 Feb 2020