Contributions
2,238 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (Second sitting)Q Could you set out what would make a proper scrutiny process for this legislation? Dr Fox: You are inviting me to give away the Hansard Society’s review proposals before we have…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (Second sitting)Q You referred in your report to the withdrawal of the scrutiny powers in the European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 in clause 11. Could you explain what that refers to and why it…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (Second sitting)Q Good afternoon. I start with a question for you, Dr Fox. The Hansard Society report described this Bill as flawed. Would you like to expand on why you say that is the case? Dr…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (Second sitting)Q As an aside, when I quoted Hansard when I was in practice, I usually felt that that was because I did not have much else to go on. I go back to what Sir Richard said about the…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (Second sitting)Q Does that mean that, in essence, developments will be dictated by what case law comes before the courts? Jack Williams : It does dictate what matters are litigated and which…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (Second sitting)Q 67 Good afternoon, Sir Gary, and good afternoon, gentlemen. You all have a great deal of experience in advising people. You will be familiar with clause 7 in particular and the…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Yes. Tom Sharpe: Shall I kick off? I know that Martin has some fairly strong views on this. What the Department is trying to do here is to provide some illustrative guidance as to…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Q That is fine. I will refer back to that. I seek some free legal advice in relation to subsections (3) and (4) of clause 7, which are about the criteria for departing from…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)I am indeed. It is the best type. Tom Sharpe: The honest answer is no. However, your excellent House of Commons research paper does indeed advert to this and describes the…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Q Good morning, gentlemen. May I ask a rather specific question? I am presuming that you have read the Bill. Under clause 4, there is a reference to removing references to…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)I see that George Peretz has joined us. I do not know whether he wanted to respond to any of the questions first of all.08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Q Just following up on the burdens issue, obviously lawyers can argue all day what a burden is. For us parliamentarians, whose opinion is it that this is reducing a burden? How…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Q Obviously, the vote to leave was over six years ago. Would it be reasonable for the Government to have said by now which laws they intend to retain, and which they intend to…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Q Would you accept that we do not actually know what the Government’s plans are at the moment? Sir Stephen Laws: Yes, I would, because they have not told you what they aim to do…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Q You referred to there being ways to identify politically salient pieces of legislation. How do you see that happening if the Bill becomes law? Sir Stephen Laws: By the support…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Q Are there adequate safeguards for scrutiny of the way in which this legislation will proceed? Sir Stephen Laws: The way in which it is scrutinised is a matter for Parliament to…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (Second sitting)On a point of order, Sir Gary. With reference to the Minister’s clarification earlier in respect of the story about the National Archives, from what she said I understand that…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)That is fine.08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (Second sitting)Q I want to return to one point you mentioned, which was interesting because it contradicted what some of the witnesses said earlier on. They said that one reason we do not need…08 Nov 2022HANSARDRetained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Bill (First sitting)Q Thank you for that news; I was not aware that there are another 1,400 pieces of legislation. I hope that the National Archives will send that information to the Minister, if not…08 Nov 2022