Contributions
3,413 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsWith this it will be convenient to discuss motion 2: That this House approves the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union under Article 50 of the Treaty on…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI will come to the right hon. and learned Gentleman, but I call Mr John Baron.19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsThat is a matter of extraordinary interest in the House and possibly across the nation—I say that to the hon. Gentleman in the friendliest spirit—but it is not a matter for…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsOrder. Mr Hughes, you are a most eccentric denizen of the House. The shadow Secretary of State for Brexit is not conducting a private conversation with you. Calm yourself!19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsOrder. We do not need people, in a rather juvenile fashion, calling out. The right hon. and learned Gentleman will give way if and when he wants to give way, as was true of the…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsOrder. We are extraordinarily grateful, more grateful than ever before, to the right hon. and learned Gentleman. The five-minute limit still applies, but the right hon. Member for…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI call Liz Saville Roberts. The right hon. Lady is not in her place. I beg her pardon; I did not intend her any discourtesy.19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsOrder. The Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster is not currently giving way.19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI do not mean it in any spirit of discourtesy to the right hon. Gentleman, but I think his contribution was rhetorical in the sense that I do not think he was particularly…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsOrder. I recognise that there are very strongly held views on both sides of the House and on both sides of this debate, but the leader of the Liberal Democrats must be heard. It…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI am grateful to the right hon. Gentleman.19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI hope the hon. Gentleman will take it in the right spirit if I say that, having known him for more than 20 years, I feel that our proceedings would not be complete without a…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI am always grateful, and I am sure the House will be indebted to the hon. Gentleman for his legal exegesis. There are other views on that matter, but he has registered his with…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsOrder. If Members are leaving the Chamber—I understand the disappointment of the hon. and learned Lady, but I cannot compel Members to remain. I cannot, to coin a phrase, take…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI am not a lawyer—I say that as a matter of some very considerable pride—but my understanding is that the legal position is clear. I do not dissent from what the hon. Gentleman…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI am grateful to the hon. and learned Lady. I have no expectation of being so asked. Moreover, I have no aspirations to the exalted status that would have been attained by a…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsThe short answer to that is yes. I intend no discourtesy to the Leader of the House, but it had been intimated to me—albeit not by him—that in the event of the Government being…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsIt would, of course, be most useful to have clarification on that matter. [ Interruption. ] The Clerk at the Table is waving in front of me—most helpfully, I hasten to add; it is…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsI am alert to the argument the hon. Lady has made. I think the fairest thing to say is that, as I have been advised by the Clerk, a ruling on Monday on this matter would be…19 Oct 2019HANSARD European Union (Withdrawal) ActsThe Government can put things on the Order Paper, but I repeat that this was not an emergency business statement. It could have been, but it was not, and that is a deeply relevant…19 Oct 2019