Contributions
3,413 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDPoints of OrderI have already explained the situation that appertains to the amendment. I do not wish to be unkind to the hon. Gentleman, but if, after all these exchanges, he is still not clear…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderI am very grateful to the hon. Lady. She, like many others, has made her position very clear, and that stands on the record for people to scrutinise. On the issues to be voted on…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderI am not confirming or denying that. I am saying what I said earlier, which is that I had a discussion with the Clerk and with other Clerks. We discussed the situation, the…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderMy understanding is that the motion today, and the amendment, are undebatable: there is to be no debate on them. I have not made, as the hon. Gentleman suggests, a change of…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderThe short answer is yes, the hon. Gentleman is right. [Interruption.] The hon. Gentleman is right: only statute can overrule statute. As usual the hon. Gentleman’s exegesis of the…09 Jan 2019HANSARDEngagementsOrder. The question from the hon. Gentleman must be heard. As I scarcely heard what he said, I think he should start again— [ Interruption. ] Yes, he should start again and…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderThe hon. Lady has made her own points with force and style. I think we all know— [ Interruption. ] Let me put it like this; I will not get into that. I think we all know from our…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderI am immensely grateful to the hon. Gentleman. I am not in the business of invoking precedent, nor am I under any obligation to do so. I think the hon. Gentleman will know that it…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderThank you.09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderNo, there is no further.09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderThe answer is that I have discussed the matter with the Clerk of the House. [Hon. Members: “Ah!”] Order. The Clerk offered me advice, and we talked about the situation that faces…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderOrder. I thank the Leader of the House for her point of order, and what I say to her is twofold. First, of course I consult the Clerk of the House and other senior Clerks, and I…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderIt seems entirely reasonable for me to say to the right hon. Gentleman that I would like to reflect on that matter. [Hon. Members: “Ah!”] Order. Members cavil as though there is…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderMy understanding is that the Business of the House motion was tabled yesterday afternoon by the Government; I confess I do not know at precisely what time, but my recollection and…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderNo, for the very simple reason that the terms for today, specified by the Government Chief Whip, specify no debate. If the hon. Lady asks me whether there will be a debate, the…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderI did hear those words. I did not hear a particular Member, and I did not see a Member mouth those words, but I did hear those words. I think it was most unfortunate that that was…09 Jan 2019HANSARD Armed Forces (Derogation from European Convention on Human Rights)We are on a ten-minute rule motion, so no.09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderI am happy to reflect on the second point, which is not altogether dissimilar to that raised earlier by the right hon. Member for Chingford and Woodford Green (Mr Duncan Smith).…09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderWell, that is not a motion that I can accept, but I would like to propose that we come now to the ten-minute rule motion. I call Mr Leo Docherty.09 Jan 2019HANSARDPoints of OrderI am not sure whether I want to speculate on that, but the hon. Gentleman has obviously applied his beady eye to the material on the Order Paper, and he has reached that…09 Jan 2019