Contributions
1,630 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARD Finance BillThe way that we treat private school fees and the other charges that private schools may levy has to be consistent with the VAT principles more broadly, which is why I have tried…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillThe reason why the Liberal Democrats hear this time and again from the Government Benches is that, time and again, they want all the benefits of investment without having to pay…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI am going to make some progress, because I will come to the right hon. Gentleman’s point in a moment, and I want to mention the points made by other hon. Members in the debate.…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillIn designing the Bill and making sure that it is clear, we decided to focus on those schools that provide full-time education. Following feedback during the consultation on the…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillIf the right hon. Gentleman is referring to the comments I just made in response to the shadow Minister’s remarks, teaching English as a foreign language and higher education are…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillLet me begin by thanking all hon. Members for their contributions. I will take a few moments to respond to some of the points raised and then to set out the Government’s view on…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI am going to make some progress. I thank my hon. Friends the Members for Falkirk (Euan Stainbank) and for Loughborough (Dr Sandher) for their comments. I feel that I am duty…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI thank the hon. Gentleman for his specific question. Let me just be clear that I am not giving tax advice for that particular school in my response, because I would always assume…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillMy hon. Friend is right to point out that decisions on VAT reliefs are political choices. Indeed, the Opposition are showing which side of that choice they land on when it comes…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillGiven the record of the Conservatives over the past 14 years, I do not think it is ridiculous to assume that they might need some education on how public finances work, with the…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI will not give way because I am making a clear point. We have to make choices in politics about what to prioritise. We have said that the VAT tax break for private school fees is…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillLet me explain to the hon. Gentleman how public finances work. Funding a tax relief or a tax break is equivalent to public spending, because it is money that cannot be spent on…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillLocal authorities and schools already have processes in place to support pupils who move between schools at any point in the academic year. Analysis carried out by the Department…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillIt is right that these changes be implemented as soon as possible to raise the funding that we need to deliver on our education priorities. As a result of the policies coming into…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI thank the right hon. Gentleman for his question on the impact of the policies on children’s education. I will come to the details shortly, but to give him an overview of the…11 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillAt the Budget in October, the Chancellor set out the decisions that we are taking to restore economic stability, put the public finances on a firm footing, and embed fiscal…10 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI thank hon. Members for their contributions to the debate. I will respond to some of the points raised, and set out the Government’s views on the new clauses. The Opposition…10 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI would like to explain to the hon. Gentleman how the energy security investment mechanism works, because that, to be fair, was put in place by the previous Government, and we are…10 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI hope that my hon. Friend’s constituents will benefit from lower bills as a result of the investment that we are ensuring, by the public and private sectors, in the clean energy…10 Dec 2024HANSARD Finance BillI am not entirely clear that that is what the Liberal Democrat amendment does. We have been clear that our intention is to end unjustifiably generous allowances. That is exactly…10 Dec 2024