Contributions
1,612 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Third sitting)Q I know that the Office for Students has received two letters recently from the Secretary of State, directing you to reduce the regulatory burden on higher education providers.…13 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Thank you for your evidence, which has been extremely interesting. I am going to ask similar questions to those I asked earlier about the director of freedom of speech. In the…13 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I agree on complexity. In your evidence, you highlight where legislation must be taken into account: the public sector equality duty, the Equality Act 2010, the…13 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q In the Bill as it stands, there is no right to appeal the decision made by the director for freedom of speech. We have already heard that it could be a political appointment, as…13 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Fourth sitting)Q This is not just about free speech within the law. Conservative Members may not recall that the Minister wrote to universities asking them to adopt the definition of…13 Sept 2021HANSARDCovid Vaccine PassportsThe Minister cannot underestimate how much freedom has been limited for those with medical exemptions. I have heard from some of my constituents that they feared even leaving the…08 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Second sitting)Q Absolutely. You could have someone who has lost an election and is put in a position of power by the Government of the day making the final decision on what is or is not freedom…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Second sitting)Q I am interested in hearing your opinions on a couple of things. Earlier, when you were answering questions from John, you were talking about tort and how the process works. I…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Second sitting)Q Would you therefore recommend an amendment to the Bill to make it explicit that local complaints processes should first be exhausted? Smita Jamdar: Absolutely.07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Second sitting)Yes—sorry. Smita Jamdar: I may have misunderstood; I do apologise. Yes, that is a concern. Built into certain types of court proceedings—judicial review, for example—is the…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Second sitting)Q On that direct point—thank you for letting me come in—the Secretary of State said on Second Reading that this “legal route”, the “new statutory tort”, is “an important…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Second sitting)Q Finally and quickly, I think I have almost achieved the impossible in that so far every academic has agreed. Do you share the concern around the change in wording from the…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Second sitting)Q That is really interesting. So you would want to see amendments to the Bill that gave students the right to continue to protest, and not therefore fall under the guidance of the…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (Second sitting)Q Professor Whittle, I want to turn again to the evidence submitted by the University of Cambridge, which highlights the tension that the Bill presents in balancing free speech…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (First sitting)Q Yes. Just to quote from the submission, “it is arguable that freedom of speech would take primacy over academic freedom when the duty is balanced in practice (i.e. you can read…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (First sitting)Q Further to that—I highlight this for Government Members, because they seem to be a little confused about who is covered by the Bill, so I refer to the Taylor Vinters submission…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (First sitting)Q I would like to return the focus to what is written in the Bill, rather than to re-argue the Second Reading arguments on the merits of whether we should have a Bill or not.…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (First sitting)Q But for institutions and those working in institutions, surely we should be promoting academic freedom? Professor Stock: I took it as implicit. I did think it was slightly…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (First sitting)Q Yes. We had evidence on this issue around a field of expertise and the overlapping between the different academic areas and who would define whether you have a field of…07 Sept 2021HANSARD Higher Education (Freedom of Speech) Bill (First sitting)Q Good morning to you both and thank you for being here. On the issue of academic freedom, I want to turn to what the Bill does and does not say. I am looking at the evidence…07 Sept 2021