Contributions
1,480 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)Forgive me, Mr Vickers; I will get to the point a little more briefly, but the whole point is that the person has to be appointed through the CQC. The CQC will make that decision,…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)It is a relief that we have not dropped clause 11, an important clause. Equally important is clause 12, on the appointment of a doctor to provide a second opinion. The clause will…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)I will speak to clause 8 first, then work my way through the other provisions in the group. The clause will introduce a statutory requirement that medical treatment under the Act…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)You have actually caught me at a perfect point, Mr Vickers. The concept of therapeutic benefit is central to the second opinion doctor’s assessment. However, in clinical practice,…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)My hon. Friend is a shrewd surveyor of legislation, and even foresees the amendments that I have tabled, which may well expose and shine a little light on something that might…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)I rise to speak on an essential aspect of our mental health system: the role of mental health tribunals, and the proposed changes to the grounds upon which they can discharge…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)There are a few questions to be answered. Given the nature of acquired brain injury—for example, the capacity of someone who has had a stroke can fluctuate—it is very hard from a…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)It is an excellent and eagle-eyed point. I would point to the evidence base that I cited, starting from 1988 onwards. That is three and half decades’ worth of evidence that points…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)If the Minister will forgive me, I was not being facetious when asking for numbers; I was simply using it as an example. I am grateful to his officials for providing the numbers…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)The Minister makes an excellent point, and that is part of the reason why the Opposition did not want to spring this question on the Government in an amendment or a vote, but…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)Clause 20 addresses a central principle in healthcare, ethics and law: the right of individuals to make informed decisions about their treatment, and the conditions under which…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)I cannot resist the opportunity to probe the Minister on something so important. He said that NHS England will predominantly look at this, but changes are happening there. Will he…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)I welcome the Government’s recognition that modern technology can play a valuable role in improving care in the mental health system. The move to allow remote interviews and…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)I would be grateful if the Minister could comment on the certificates being combined. There is a concern, if we go from two certificates to one, that the reason why two…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Third sitting)My hon. Friend is spot on about training. It is one thing to enshrine these measures in primary legislation; it is another thing to have the training and interpretation that go…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)I am grateful for the opportunity to scrutinise clauses 13 and 14. Clause 13 will make significant amendments to how medical treatment is administered under the Mental Health Act…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)I appreciate the hon. Lady’s insight, both as a politician and as a patient. I guess the Opposition are concerned that there is no explicit duty here, which is why legislating for…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Third sitting)My hon. Friend makes an important and poignant point. The Government have rightly stated that this change could take up to 10 years to implement, but we need to ensure that the…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Fourth sitting)The hon. Lady makes an excellent point. This is especially relevant when capacity fluctuates in some patients, which we expect to see more often with the kind of dementia that…12 Jun 2025HANSARDMental Health Bill [ Lords ] (Third sitting)It is a pleasure to be here on day two in Committee. I will first address clause 5 and then the Government amendments. The clause marks significant reform to the legal foundations…12 Jun 2025