Contributions
1,270 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q Is it ever an element of the community resolution process that a perpetrator might agree to make some kind of financial compensation voluntarily? Rebecca Bryant: That is not…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q Good morning. I am Dr Kieran Mullan, a shadow Justice Minister. The antisocial behaviour that your work focuses on is often resolved, at least initially, through non-custodial…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q A final question from me. I am conscious of time, so I will direct this question to Dame Nicole because of your particular expertise in domestic abuse. You will be aware that…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q I want to move on to questions about the victim personal statement, commonly referred to as a victim impact statement. I know we have discussed this, and there is widespread…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q I am Dr Kieran Mullan, the shadow Justice Minister. I should say for transparency that I have had the opportunity to meet Katie and Baroness Newlove to discuss some of the…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q Thank you. One of the amendments that the Opposition are tabling would introduce a greater freedom for victims and family members to speak more freely in their victim impact…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Finally, I just point out again that our amendment addresses the issue of making threats, for example. Those are things that you cannot do anyway, in terms of free speech, so our…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q I just point out that the statement is used post conviction, so it would not influence the jury—it is for the judge. Do you accept that our amendment, which emphasises that it…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Finally, you will have heard again the evidence that the witnesses gave in relation to changes to the personal impact statements. I know you are passionate about victims’…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q The overwhelming weight of the evidence that we heard from witnesses today—it was almost universal—was in support of an extension of the scheme, but that was not enough to…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Fine. Great. Thank you for your agreement that it can be done. Moving on to the ULS scheme, you have mentioned, both in the Chamber and in your questions today, that the Law…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q So can we agree that there is not anything in principle that would stop the Government instigating such a measure as is proposed in our amendment? Alex Davies-Jones: I would…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q I think they said on the record that they consider themselves to have expertise in that area. Would you accept that they both agreed that it would be possible in principle to…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Would you accept that Mr Jennings and Deputy Chief Constable Telfer, as they described, have expertise in the use of force and the physical management of offenders? Alex…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Great. What is your understanding of the US legal framework when it comes to the use of force, including, for example, restraining or gagging defendants in court? Alex…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Let me help you, Minister. It says that it should not change it. Its current proposals are that there should not be any changes to the ULS scheme from the perspective of victims…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q I will start by asking you to talk about the context through which the MOJ looks at what it can learn from international examples. For example, can you confirm that, in other…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Okay, but taking you back to the question, what is your understanding of what the Law Commission currently says are its proposals for changes to the ULS? Alex Davies-Jones: It…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q I will move on to talk about the expansion of the victim contact scheme. Are there resource implications for the service in extending it, and what are your initial views on how…17 Jun 2025HANSARDVictims and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q If I were to tell you, and it is true, that the US judicial system has a specific legal power to allow people to be restrained and gagged as part of court proceedings—they have…17 Jun 2025