Contributions
1,270 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)I am the shadow Justice Minister. To start with, may I just check how you would like to be addressed? Judge Durran: “Judge”—is that easiest?27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Thank you, Judge. Judge Durran: It is either that or “Chief”, and I think perhaps “Judge” sounds more formal.27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)We get to question the Minister at the end of the process, so that is a helpful thing for you to have given to us to think about.27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)You are doing a great job.27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q I am the shadow Minister. Could you begin by telling us, given your experience of what happened at Grenfell and the investigations that followed, the key things that you think…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q Hello, Chief Constable Guildford, I am the shadow Justice Minister. Obviously police officers are already under considerable obligations in terms of their conduct. What gaps do…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Some people say there is and some people say there is not; I guess it is for us to try to work that out. Thank you for your assistance.27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q How do we ensure that the right people are caught by these offences? I am aware that you can have a culture in an organisation where senior leadership can create an expectation…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q Thank you, Ms Butts, for coming to give evidence. I am Kieran, the shadow Justice Minister. I do not know whether you heard any of the earlier evidence, but one of our…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q I am the shadow Minister. Earlier, we heard clear evidence from families and from an organisation representing families, Inquest, about the imbalance in legal representation at…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q The Bill’s provisions essentially ask public bodies to ensure just that they are representing themselves in a “reasonable” manner. How would you even begin to advise a public…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q What provisions in the Bill could be most helpful to the sorts of people you will be seeking to represent? In what areas, if any, do you think the Bill could be changed? Cindy…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q Thank you for that opening statement. It applies to anybody who might have criticisms of elements of the Bill or views on it; we should not translate those into a lack of…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q I do not know whether you heard, but in an earlier session I asked how we are going to decide what is sufficient or adequate representation for public authorities. The evidence…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q We also heard in evidence that court judges in other settings make decisions about appropriate costs and so on. With some training and support, could coroners be asked to fulfil…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q This is a separate line of questioning, but the question of whether the experience of the coroners process is always a positive one for families is not a new issue. Some of my…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q Are those your key points? I have some further questions. Cindy Butts: They are my key points, but I think there is one more that I want to bring to your attention. As the Bill…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q Okay. On the first point you made about language, are there specific ways in which you would change the language? Would there be different words or terminology? Cindy Butts:…27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)It would be; thank you.27 Nov 2025HANSARDPublic Office (Accountability) Bill (Second sitting)Q Do you think we need another body to do the job of following up on PFDs specifically? Professor Fowler: No, I do not think we do.27 Nov 2025