Contributions
1,270 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)The point was made very powerfully in the evidence sessions that we have this idea that we have to take a lot of time to explain all this complex stuff to a jury, and that we can…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)Yes, I accept that, to a degree, the Government have attempted to put in place safeguards. The question is: what weight can be given to those safeguards? We had a discussion…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I will just finish my point. If we were confident that this would deliver the outcome that the Government claim it will, then things would be different, but we question whether it…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I will take this opportunity to address some of the points raised in this morning’s debate, and to expand on areas that were points of contention. There was healthy debate about…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I do. In the other direction, the Institute for Government highlights that “only around 30% of sentences of 6-12 months were handed out by magistrates” since their sentencing…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)Sometimes I wish that Government Members would pay more attention to what is being said. I mentioned “some” cases and “some” of these people. That is the difference in how we…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)Those aspects link directly, because I am discussing particular disclosure issues occurring in the magistrates court. As I will go on to explain, these are specific problems that…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)They are working very hard, as the Minister says, but the work is not complete. We have not done what the Under-Secretary of State for Justice said we should, which is do the…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I have explained why I have concerns about whether the judiciary is sufficiently accountable for the decisions and positions that it takes under the current system. I am not…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)The Minister put that question very succinctly, in exactly the same way, to members of the criminal Bar, who know much more about this than me; they were very clear that they did…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)indicated assent .14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)As I said, it is about weighing the benefits that the Minister has rightly articulated against the loss of the benefit of safeguarding individual people who are perhaps erring…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I rise to speak in support of amendment 39 tabled in my name. As I touched on earlier this morning, along with amendments 23 and 24—which are driving at the same point, but in…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I will finish the sentence, and then I will. Of course, we would assume that they had done that in consultation with other leadership figures, so we might reasonably say that they…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)That potential benefit has to be weighed against what we discussed earlier. For a very good reason, our system explicitly prevents the jury’s inner working from being subject to…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)rose—14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)I am afraid that we are again at violent agreement and disagreement at the same time. The principle that hon. Member is talking about is absolutely fair. There will be a period of…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)We have talked about the issue of safeguards against prejudice, and it is not a view just shared by people such as the Secretary of State for Justice. The CBA commissioned an…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)The Minister is factually incorrect. The engagement session was not today, but yesterday. I met Sir Brian, my hon. Friend the Member for West Suffolk (Nick Timothy) met Sir Brian,…14 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fourth sitting)Yes, and I have made that point in other debates on this issue: we cannot say that with absolute certainly. The Deputy Prime Minister is clear—I think his phrase was that we have…14 Apr 2026