Contributions
1,270 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)Will the Minister give way on that point?16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)Will the Minister give way on that point?16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)I talked about how the medical picture can evolve in a worsening situation. We can also get that situation in reverse. For example, in A&E, the A&E consultant’s interpretation of…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)We went through this at the start. A triable either-way decision becomes a trial on indictment, but I have been told by a leading KC that in pre-trial hearings—the sort of matters…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)I think the Minister would accept that it is a high bar, but also that it is sometimes successfully crossed. Allocations are sometimes successfully challenged, which demonstrates…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)Again, this is why the Minister needs to clearly articulate whether or not we can— [ Interruption. ] The hon. Member for Amber Valley is saying that the Minister said that we can.…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)I beg to move amendment 42, in clause 3, page 9, line 23, leave out subsection (4) and insert— “(4) Where a court has determined in accordance with section 74A that a trial is to…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)I think that wanting defendants to have the ability to challenge allocation decisions as they stand under a new court is pretty intellectually coherent. I am arguing that these…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)If the Minister wants to intervene on me and say, “I am absolutely certain that there would be a right to judicially review the allocation decision by a Crown court,” I will be…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)To return to the heart of the matter, I will pick up on the comments made by my hon. Friend the Member for Isle of Wight East on an issue that I had not talked about. I talked…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)This is very important. I have read the legislation to the Minister, and highlighted the point that a non-conviction element of the Crown court proceedings cannot be taken to…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)That goes straight to the point we discussed earlier about why it is important to separate the two, because in this scenario it is the same person all the way through. Ultimately,…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)Why does the Minister think it is important that some cases remain with a jury trial? What are the material differences that she sees between a jury trial and a non-jury trial…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)Sorry—with confidence. The Minister says she is happy to go away and double-check. She should know for certain whether people have a right to a judicial review of an allocation…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)Just so we are really clear, I have met Supreme Court judges and they tell me that they go back through discussions and debates about legislation to understand the intent or will…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Fifth sitting)I covered that in earlier remarks, when I pointed out that those people are not adults, so it is a different set of circumstances. If the hon. Member is asking me to be…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)As I said, our preference is for an appeal. The Government could say, “We are not going to add additional rights that do not exist; you do not get a right of appeal on allocation…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)I absolutely agree. We will go on to discuss reallocation, and the hon. Member anticipates the points I was going to make. The reallocation decision is even more of a minefield,…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)I beg to move amendment 41, in clause 3, page 5, line 38, at end insert— “(7) Where a court has determined in accordance with this section that a trial is to be conducted without…16 Apr 2026HANSARDCourts and Tribunals Bill (Sixth sitting)Perhaps the Minister is sincerely—not deliberately—misunderstanding the point I make.16 Apr 2026