Contributions
1,800 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)I am grateful for that explanation. We had quite a discussion of some of these issues last week. Unfortunately, it appears that there is a second policy paper, which I am not sure…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)But before people start applying cold compresses to their heads, I assure the Committee that I will not subject that document to detailed scrutiny. Some of it would have been…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)I understand the difficulty, but I think this is a pretty important point. This is a framework Bill, but people are looking for certainty over the next couple of years and will…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)I beg to move amendment 74, in clause 13, page 11, line 8, leave out subsection (4) and insert— “(4) Regulations under this section shall make provision for circumstances in which…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)We will do that. Turning to clause 13, de-linking is significant for our farmers and there is a worry around it. The House of Commons Library briefing talks about the effect and…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)I beg to move amendment 7, in clause 17, page 14, line 20, leave out “five years” and insert “year”. I am very happy to move this amendment; as keen-eyed Members might notice, it…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)I agree with my hon. Friend. We need much more clarity. The clause is clearly not strong enough, at a time when food security has the potential to become a major cause of…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)The Minister makes a fine attempt, but I am afraid that this is a basic issue of trust. Governments are rarely trusted, however hard they try. She asks us to take this on trust,…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)I beg to move amendment 75, in clause 17, page 14, line 25, at end insert— “(aa) the impact of food production upon global resource sustainability (including global carbon…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)Before speaking on the clause, I give the Minister advance notice that I will also say a word on clause 22, on data. I draw attention to paragraph 170 of the explanatory notes to…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)That is an important intervention, and I am grateful to my hon. Friend for mentioning the evidence of the Tenant Farmers Association. There is a bigger debate to be had—the…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Ninth sitting)I apologise, Mr Stringer, for not listing the clause earlier as one on which I wanted to make an observation. I should declare—I am a bit of a data person—that I run the all-party…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Tenth sitting)I am thinking back to our earlier discussion on data throughout the entire system. Why do some sectors need to be treated differently here, but did not when it came to the…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Tenth sitting)A number of these amendments relate to wider devolution issues; my comments are applicable to a number of them, in particular those that we are discussing at the moment. We are…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Tenth sitting)This is a complicated set of issues, and I seek clarification. Some lack of clarity about post-1995 holdings has been raised with me. The question is, going back to the financial…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Tenth sitting)I beg to move amendment 84, in clause 35, page 31, line 38, leave out “may” and insert “must”. This amendment would make it a duty for the Secretary of State to make regulations…03 Mar 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Eighth sitting)The Minister has given a welcome clarification. The obvious rejoinder is: where is the headroom in the DEFRA budget for these very ambitious plans? I suspect we will return to…27 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Eighth sitting)Today’s discussions have been most illuminating and interesting and have shown the benefit of giving the proposals detailed scrutiny. To refer to my earlier comments, it would be…27 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Eighth sitting)Oh, I have. In which case, I withdraw that suggestion. I understand what the Minister is saying. She is trying to find a balance between an appropriate level of involvement…27 Feb 2020HANSARDAgriculture Bill (Eighth sitting)I will read it; I promise. Guidance will be provided to everyone who participates in ELMS, including guidance on how to deliver the environmental outcomes that they will pay for.…27 Feb 2020