Contributions
1,800 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Good afternoon to our witnesses. Minette, could I start with you? On livestock attacks, do you think that the maximum fine of £1,000 is sufficient? Minette Batters: No, and it…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q I suspect that this is a slightly leading question, but do you think there is sufficient compensation for farmers whose livestock have been attacked? Minette Batters: With the…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Good afternoon. You may well have heard some of the evidence given by previous witnesses, but to return to the importation of dogs and cats in a vehicle, what is your view on…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q I put this question to one of our earlier witnesses. There are pretty strong measures in the Bill to deal with puppy and dog smuggling, but there is a view that some of those…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q You may well have heard the discussion earlier about so-called fashion-based mutilations. Does the Bill do enough to tackle those? Rob Quest: We agree wholeheartedly with…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q From your experience, how confident can we be that the various authorities charged with enforcement have the resources, training, numbers and skills to do what we expect them…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Should there be visual checks? Rob Quest: You need to have a visual check; otherwise, you will not know whether the animals have been cropped and docked.09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q To what extent should the responsibility lie with the carrier? Rob Quest: If they do a visual check, it is easy to tell that a dog has had its ears cropped. It could be a…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Indeed. Would you like to say a little more about what those issues might be? Rob Quest: Resources would be the main one, and the priorities of officials at ports. If the…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Thank you very much; that is very helpful.09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Finally, on zoos there is a specific ask to change the term “specialist” to “expert”. Could you explain the thinking behind that? Justine Shotton: Absolutely. The Royal College…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q That was a brilliant politician’s answer, if I may say, because I am not entirely sure where you are on leads after that. Never mind; I get the drift. I will move on to the…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Good afternoon. Thank you for giving us your time and expertise. I will run through things in the order that the Bill covers them, starting with primates. In your written…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q I think what I took from that is that you would prefer a ban. Justine Shotton: We would prefer a ban, unless the licensing standards are extremely high, so that licensing really…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Moving on to attacks on livestock, we have basically reduced this down to a question of whether you are in favour of leads. Do you think dogs should be on a lead? Justine…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q On export for slaughter, a lot of this ground has been covered by other witnesses, but I noticed that in your written evidence, you talked about certified training for farmers,…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Thank you. On the import of dogs and cats, you have already made the point about pre-import testing. Again, how would that work in practice? What are the implications? Justine…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Good afternoon. Following up on that question, are you satisfied to that extent with the measures in the Bill or do you think that dogs should be kept on a lead near livestock?…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (Second sitting)Q Given what a big issue it is, do you think that the fines and the compensation mechanisms to farmers are sufficient? Dr Wright: No, I do not, actually. Because there are repeat…09 Nov 2021HANSARDAnimal Welfare (Kept Animals) Bill (First sitting)I will try not to hog the witnesses, but may I ask two more questions?09 Nov 2021