Contributions
1,319 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q Sorry, but are you talking about domestic actors—domestic political parties in their engagement in domestic politics—rather than foreign state involvement? Carl Miller: Yes. One…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (First sitting)That is over a number of years, of course. Jonathan Hall: Yes. The maximum I remember in any year is up to six; at the moment it is down to about two. The authorities ran quite a…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (First sitting)Q Mr Hall, thank you for being with us this morning. Coming back to STPIMs, you spoke with the shadow Minister a little bit about effectiveness but I want to ask for your thoughts…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q I was not trying to start an argument or even a discussion or analysis of end-to-end encryption. I was just asking, relatively speaking, how much do we know? There is a…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)But that is still more than you can see on WhatsApp, where you cannot see a post at all. Poppy Wood: That’s true. I suppose I would say they could do much more about transparency…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q You mentioned that there is not transparency, but there is at least one type of transparency with Facebook—main Facebook—as in you can see what is on it. I wonder what you think…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q Would it be fair to say that they have at least got better? If you take the American 2020 election, there does not seem to have been the same volume of attempted disruption as…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q Hello. Earlier, you queried why something that happened in 2014 might only have been called out by Facebook in 2018. Isn’t it quite obvious that what happened was 2016 in the…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q Turning to Law Commission colleagues, you have conducted a very comprehensive review of the four Official Secrets Acts. Let us set aside the Official Secrets Act 1989, which is,…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (First sitting)Q In terms of their usefulness in the suite of what is available in order to counter these threats in the terrorism field, which obviously is your primary area of expertise, can…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (First sitting)Q Given that there is obviously a lower burden of proof—there is no court case—and given the numbers of TPIMs that we have spoken about, are you satisfied that the proportionality…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q So you are not saying that you think that lawyers should be exempted from registering? Your objection is specifically about disclosure of documentation. Rich Owen: Yes. Well, we…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (First sitting)Q Sir David, you have a long sweep of history to look back at, with GCHQ and your role as the first security and intelligence co-ordinator, and now in academia. Sir Alex was…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (First sitting)Q How do you see information operations working? How might foreign states seek to interfere in our democratic processes and public life? Professor Sir David Omand : If you recall…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q What would the loopholes or potential unintended consequences be to such a provision, and how would you guard against them? Rich Owen: It is important to know the limits to…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (First sitting)Q I realise that we have a tiny amount of time left. It is the curse of these things that we have to finish exactly on time, because we are just getting into this very interesting…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q Mr Miller, to come back to information ops, what do we know about scale of state-enacted or state-sponsored information operations specifically? Carl Miller: One suggestion that…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q I turn to Mr Owen, briefly, to ask about the forthcoming foreign influence registration scheme. From your perspective, what would be your hopes on behalf of the legal profession…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)Q Professor Martin, one of the core aims of this legislation is to bring our counter-espionage capability up to date with the modern world. You spoke a little earlier about data…07 Jul 2022HANSARDNational Security Bill (Second sitting)But you can see public postings on Facebook. That is my point. Poppy Wood: On your page, you can, but researchers cannot.07 Jul 2022