Contributions
1,674 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)As I said, I am a massive fan of standards development. I have worked in the area, with the ITU. I agree that it is essential to enable open RAN and diversification. The…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q That is really helpful. What you are saying is that although you could deliver a full-service 2G, 3G, 4G or 5G network tomorrow, that is not what our mobile operators want. They…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q That is very helpful. I think you said that a site would connect not with fibre, but with something else. Stefano Cantarelli: Not only with fibre. The open RAN interface is such…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q So you couldn’t provide a network tomorrow, but you could provide a network in how long—a 2, 3, 4 or 5G network? Pardeep Kohli: So if the frequency band radios are available…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q Who builds the radios? Pardeep Kohli: Today, because it has always been proprietary solutions, that is where the challenge comes for companies like us, because it is demand and…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)It is computing—it is processors. Pardeep Kohli: That is correct. You get processors for CPU or general-purpose computing, or even if there are some accelerators, which we use for…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Sorry—say that again. I could not hear that. What is the rest of it? Pardeep Kohli: It is general-purpose open compute; it is already available hardware.14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Thank you. That is very helpful. That makes me think that there are security issues arising from, for example, having our cloud infrastructure dominated by one vendor, such as…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q Thank you for joining us today. Having read your bios, I am impressed by the breadth, geographic as well as technical and operational, of your experience. To make this concrete…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q I did not think I would get a chance to ask further questions. I respect your reluctance, if you like, to voice criticisms at this stage, but can I just get a further idea on…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q To clarify that point, you are happy with the existing level of scrutiny and involvement of the security services in the development of the framework and the review of the…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q So, what are other countries doing that you are aware of? Hamish MacLeod: The States, New Zealand and Australia have all excluded Huawei, among others. We could supply you with…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q Thank you, Mr McCabe. I was going to ask on behalf of my colleague, Catherine West, who cannot be here because we have chosen to sit physically rather than remotely. […14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (First sitting)Q Finally, with regard to having only two vendors for the mobile network for a number of years, can I ask two questions? I think that there has been a little discussion about…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (First sitting)Q Can you say why the risk profile is different for fixed as opposed to mobile? Howard Watson: Fundamentally, you are dealing with a customer that is a fixed end point, so you are…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (First sitting)Q I was interested in what you said about the weakest link for networks. I agree wholeheartedly with that. What are your thoughts on fixed networks? While the Government are…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q I am the shadow Minister for the Bill. Let me start by welcoming you and thanking you very much for your expert input. I particularly welcome you, Dr Bennett, for your expertise…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (First sitting)Q Do you not think resilience is part of security? Is a network secure if it is not resilient? Alex Towers: I think they overlap and that is one of our questions about the…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (First sitting)Q Thanks very much for joining us. We have heard that open RAN will not be mature for another eight years. Do you agree with that assessment? In that case, as you have outlined,…14 Jan 2021HANSARDTelecommunications (Security) Bill (Second sitting)Q To follow up briefly on that, I think what you are saying is that there might be a contradiction between the desire to have a more diverse supply chain, with more smaller…14 Jan 2021