Contributions
997 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q Has your association identified the sources that you would like to be able to access? Peter Stanyon: I think the Department for Work and Pensions database is, at the moment,…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q Can I ask about how we devise the electoral register? Do you think there should be any changes to the way we do that, and any sources of information that are currently denied…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q Earlier you mentioned that you favoured 650 MPs. You were concerned about going down to 600 and giving the payroll a greater proportional say. You also in answer to the Minister…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q Are there any sources of information that electoral registration officers would like to have access to and that they currently cannot access, which would assist them in…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q Could it lead to frustration? We do not keep clearly identifiable communities with common characteristics integral within parliamentary representation, but their voices could be…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q For local administration purposes, would it be better to go to sub-ward level to keep a constituency coterminous within a local authority area than to go across two local…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q Hi Peter. What are the additional problems that are created for electoral registration officers when a constituency goes into two local authority areas that are under the…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q Can I turn to Professor McLean? Do we need more than a calculator to map out our parliamentary boundaries? Professor McLean: I would urge Members not to go down that road. Of…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q Thanks, Darren, for giving evidence this afternoon. Following on from that, do you think that the Boundary Commission is incapable of telling the difference between political…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q My final point would be that, in that case, should we not allow the Boundary Commission more flexibility than the 5%, in order to meet those concerns, where there is a genuine…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q Do you have examples of where things went wrong, where local representations were dressed up in such a way as to influence the outcome, which brought about something that was…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q That is true. There are communities within boundaries, but it is important that they are not subdivided, just to satisfy a tight, rigid, mathematical exercise, is it not?…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q That may well be true. Nonetheless, the community has an opportunity to make those representations to the Boundary Commission. Professor Sir John Curtice: There is a certain…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q But if those views are diluted because communities are divided up in a mathematical exercise, do people not become frustrated because their collective view, brought about by…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q If a community has a shared experience—perhaps, for instance, the “red wall” seats that people have talked about a lot since the last election—and wants to express a collective…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q Professor Sir John, how much does locality and shared common experience in a community influence how individuals vote? Professor Sir John Curtice: The research on this goes back…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Fourth sitting)Q I am not sure which of the two of you I am aiming this question at, but how much does locality and the experience of living in a community influence the way people vote? Does it…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q In order to achieve making sure that communities are kept intact, is it desirable that the Boundary Commission has flexibility and is not kept to a maximum of 5%? Dr Renwick: I…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (Third sitting)Q How far should we go in ensuring that whole communities are kept intact when we form a parliamentary constituency boundary, when balanced against trying to achieve equality of…23 Jun 2020HANSARDParliamentary Constituencies bill (First sitting)Q You might not want to comment on this, but would it then make sense to calculate from a high point like that, so that it is perhaps more accurate at the next general election?…18 Jun 2020