Contributions
2,992 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q When I was asking questions on Tuesday, the representative of Meta made a second claim that raised my eyebrow. He claimed that, in designing its algorithms, it did not primarily…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Thank you for joining us and giving evidence, Frances; it is nice to see you again. We had evidence from Meta, your former employer, on Tuesday, in which its representative…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I want to pick up on Martin Lewis’s point about enforcement. He said that he had to sue Facebook himself, which was no doubt an onerous, painful and costly enterprise—at least…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q In clause 35 there is the drafting point that we are looking at. It says “minimise the risk” instead of “prevent”. You are right to point out that drafting issue. In relation to…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Mr Fassam, I will address those two questions, if I may. Search is covered by clause 35 and user-generated content is subject to the Bill’s general provisions on user-generated…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I thank the witnesses for joining us this afternoon, and particularly Martin Lewis for his campaigning in this area. I will start by agreeing with the point that Martin Lewis…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Yes, but with the amendment committed to on Second Reading, you would say that the Bill does meet those freedom of speech objectives, subject to the detail. Owen Meredith:…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Thank you; that is very helpful. I have only one other question. In relation to questions concerning freedom of speech, the Government believe, and I believe, that the Bill very…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Thank you. So you are categorically satisfied about the risks that we have heard articulated; that maleficent actors would not be able to set themselves up in such a way that…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Thank you. Can I move on to the question that Kim Leadbeater asked a moment ago, and that a number of Members have raised? You very kindly said a moment ago that you thought…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Can I start by clarifying a comment that Owen Meredith made at the very beginning? You were commenting on where you would like the Bill to go further in protecting media…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q I appreciate that; thank you, Sir Roger. Ms Wood, you mentioned misinformation in your earlier remarks—I say “misinformation” rather than “state-sponsored disinformation”, which…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Goodness! There is a lot to ask about.26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Thank you, Ms Perry. Finally, Mr Bhandari, some people have raised concerns about free speech. I do not share those concerns—in fact, I rebutted them a Times article earlier…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Yes. There are strong powers in the Bill for Ofcom to do precisely that. Ms Perry, may I ask you same general question? Do you feel that the Bill represents a very substantial…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Before I turn to Ms Perry with the same question about the Bill’s general effect, Sanjay, you mentioned the terrible incidence of abuse that the three England footballers got…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Fourth sitting)Q Picking up that last point about representation for particular groups of users including children, Ms Perry, do you agree that the ability to designate organisations that can…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Third sitting)Q The shadow Minister’s question is related to the removal of what was clause 103 in the old draft of the Bill. As she said, that related to media literacy. Does the panel draw…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Third sitting)Q Good. Thank you, Stephen. Liron? Liron Velleman: We are satisfied that the Bill adequately protects freedom of speech. Our key view is that, if people are worried that it does…26 May 2022HANSARDOnline Safety Bill (Third sitting)Q Thank you. You made a very important point: there is nothing in the Bill that requires censorship or prohibition of content that is legal and harmless to children. That is a…26 May 2022