Contributions
838 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Ms Phillips, shared owners, under the Renters (Reform) Bill passing through Parliament, will get forfeiture: an improvement on mandatory grounds of possession for which relief…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q It really is an equity trap, isn’t it? Sue Phillips: It is. Housing associations will say that they will do their utmost to prevent this scenario playing out, and that numbers…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q If the Bill were to introduce a provision that forfeiture were abolished, so that with a debt of, say, £5,000 or £10,000, you could not lose the entire value that you have in…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Okay. As shared owners, you pay service charges as well as rent and you are disadvantaged if there is poor maintenance of your buildings. Do you agree that shared owners should…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Sorry, I couldn’t hear what you said there. Sue Phillips: Sorry. One is to do with the model and one is to do with the transparency around the model. On the model itself, in the…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q In conversation with my colleague, Matt Pennycook, you talked about the lack of statutory lease extension provision. The Law Commission said that shared owners should have the…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)No, I will leave it there.18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Ms Higgins, do you agree that it would be appropriate to allow leaseholders to withhold service charges where there has not been compliance with the very extensive requirements…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Indeed, yes. Ms Paula Higgins: I fully support something like that.18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Thank you also for what you said about wanting all new apartments to be leasehold with a share of freehold, Ms Higgins. That was echoed by Mr Smytherman. In so far as new…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q As a leaseholder with a share of freehold, if commonhold were to become available, do you think that it would be equitable and fair to charge you for the privilege of…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Professor Steven, my question is to you. Last week, in the House of Lords, the Government indicated that they were looking at the Scottish system of tenements. Could you perhaps…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Nothing takes away the capacity of people to disagree with each other. I want to ask you a further question, which Professor Hodges may also have a view on. In the early 2000s…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Just to make you feel a little better about disagreeing with your Law Commission counterparts in England, of course they were constrained in what they could do by the parameters…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Let me ask you perhaps a more difficult question: how many of the mortgages that are lent to shared equity owners default compared with normal freehold owners? Paul Broadhead:…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Professor Hodges, my colleague Richard Fuller sought to make a point about caveat emptor to you. Is it your experience that the inequity of power and information between…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Indeed. Thank you for that, and I think everyone will also want to thank you for your work on the Post Office inquiry. I want to ask you about introducing insurance commission.…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)We will hear about—18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Q Thank you very much, Professor Steven. Turning to the value of the building and property rights, we heard from an eminent lawyer on Tuesday about property rights in relation to…18 Jan 2024HANSARDLeasehold and Freehold Reform Bill (Third sitting)Thank you very much. Professor Steven? Professor Steven: I have nothing to add.18 Jan 2024