Contributions
1,207 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, I am keen to make progress on these issues in what I call bite-sized chunks. I have always referred to these two issues as being stage 2. They are the two issues that…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, I really hope that would not be the case. One of the reasons why I said we wanted to see what could be done more quickly is that some things may be able to be done by…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, it is a question of stages, and these are certainly issues we should make progress on. The more issues we discuss, the less likely we are to move forwards, as we have…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillNo, my Lords, that would not be in the remit. It would be purely on the issues of participation and retirement age.02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, we have had a bit of a rehash of a debate that we had previously in Committee on a similar amendment. Amendment 2 today is almost identical to the previous amendment,…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, I will take one more intervention. I have listened with great care to noble Lords and have not intervened on anybody, and I want to respond to those who have spoken. I…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillI would say no, because the danger is that the issues get wider and wider, and no decision is taken. Looking at these things in bite-size chunks in order to reach a conclusion and…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillI would say to my noble friend that we all have an interest in the retirement age because we all hope to approach one at some point in our lives. He is right. I am not going to…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillThose are exactly the words I wrote; we can check Hansard later. The noble Lord’s amendment is a way to slow down the process so that all those Members remain here. I speak to my…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, that is always in the hands of the electorate when they have the manifesto published before them. But again, on the retirement age, we have set that out as a clearly…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillI took interventions, so the noble Lord can accept one and be helpful. He is wrong in his premise. Hereditary Peers would remain as hereditary Peers because all that happens in…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillThe noble Lord has tabled an amendment and is offering it at this point now, although, had he been in the House when this was debated, I doubt he would have voted differently at…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, there is a sense of déjà vu all over again when we discuss these issues, as we have done a number of times. The noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, has the distinction of…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, there was an opportunity for this House. Had we not had the by-elections since 1999, there would have been far fewer hereditary Peers in this House then. Since my noble…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, I do not imagine that that would be discussed by this Select Committee, which will look at the two specific issues that have been raised. We will debate the matter that…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillThat is a valid point. The Earl Marshal has been very clear that he is perfectly content with this. I do not think this amendment is necessary. I assure the House that those…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Roberts, for an erudite and entertaining speech. His amendment is similar to one that was tabled by the noble Lord, Lord…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillMy Lords, I listened to the noble Baroness with increasing incredulity. Even she had a smile on her face as she came up with some of that. I thank my noble friend for his points.…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillI do not think so, not directly. However, if the committee is looking at retirement and participation, we would want to ensure that, post any decisions that it takes and actions…02 Jul 2025HANSARDHouse of Lords (Hereditary Peers) BillIt does not, because that is not the legislation we are talking about. That is a decision of this House, and I find it very difficult to understand why anybody would want to…02 Jul 2025