Contributions
1,032 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryNo, I will keep speaking, as is my right. Without a negotiated solution with Mauritius, it would pursue its legal campaign; it has made that very clear, as the shadow Minister…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryNo, I will not take another intervention from the right hon. Gentleman. My response was very clear. On the subject of inaccurate speculation about the cost of the treaty, Prime…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI was just about to come on to that. There have been some changes to enable a limited element of front-loading, but the overall net present value of the treaty payments, which…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI am happy to do so.26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI am grateful to the right hon. Member for Witham (Priti Patel) for bringing this Opposition debate to the House. As she knows, for over 50 years the UK-US base on Diego Garcia…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryNo, I said that I would make progress.26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryWhat I have said is that there is clear risk to critical functions of that base on Diego Garcia because of legal jeopardy. Conservative Members do not appear to be aware of those…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI know that the right hon. Gentleman understands full well that this is because of the legal uncertainty that is created by the current situation. That has been recognised time…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryNo, I will make progress.26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI will happily give way to the right hon. Gentleman.26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryThe 2019 International Court of Justice advisory opinion might be the most eye-catching of the legal developments in recent years—26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryClaims that there were no legal necessities to negotiate are absolutely wrong; they misunderstand the legal jeopardy and immediate operational challenges that the base faces.…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryThe right hon. Gentleman is well aware that of course we know about that ICJ carve-out in relation to the Commonwealth. That is common knowledge. I find it slightly strange that…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI do not want to embarrass the right hon. Gentleman, but he surely understands the difference with access to spectrum, which is the key issue here. It is critical. I find it…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean Territoryrose—26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI note that when the right hon. and learned Gentleman talked about the potential for real-world consequences coming from legal uncertainty, some on the Conservative Benches…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI give way to the hon. Member for Hinckley and Bosworth.26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryThank you, Madam Deputy Speaker. Let me explain to Conservative Members, because I feel they are perhaps unaware of the fact that the ICJ advisory opinion is simply the most…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI think that the ordinary general public would be pretty concerned about a situation in which we had the risk of joint— [ Interruption. ] Opposition Members laugh. They laugh…26 Feb 2025HANSARD British Indian Ocean TerritoryI have made that very clear previously. That carve-out for the Commonwealth is very clear within the ICJ. I think I looked at the right hon. Gentleman with a smile. If that is…26 Feb 2025