Contributions
1,005 recent contributions in Hansard
HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q And you will have seen the Government’s response to that? André Rebello: I have seen the Government’s response to that. However, being at the coalface and knowing the lack of…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q You are saying there are two separate issues: whether it is a sensible proviso, and whether there is certainty at the moment. Dr Morgan: Yes. My position is that it is a…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q I would just like to clarify some points that came up this morning about this issue. It has been said several times that with Cart reviews, there is an extra bite of the…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (First sitting)But a court might attempt to impose— Dr Morgan: For a court below the Supreme Court, the obvious precedent that the applicant would cite would be Ahmed, and it would be very hard…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q Clause 1 gives the courts a discretionary power to grant a full remedy to a claimant, but to limit the retrospective effects of the judgment for any other individual who has not…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q One other question. It appears that you heard Mr Rebello’s evidence, and you will know that I asked about some of the other recommendations of the Justice Committee, in…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q I will ask one more very quick question. Is there anything else in the Justice Committee report that you would like to see incorporated in the Bill? Perhaps list it rather than…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q Do I take that to mean that the way the proposed new section is drafted could dissuade individuals from initiating judicial review proceedings, because they may not obtain a…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q There was a reduction in resources because of the Unison case, which has now been reversed. Is that also causing problems? Richard Leiper: Yes—well, not problems, but it has…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q I have one or two quick questions on coroners. Some people have commented that the provisions in the Bill are fairly modest, particularly in light of the recent Justice…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q May I press you on that? It sounds to me that your answer is that legal aid for bereaved families in such inquests may not be necessary, even if it was desirable. However, these…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q I do have one other question on ouster but, Dr Morgan, just before we leave clause 1, you mentioned a presumption. Do I take it from what you have said already that you are…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (First sitting)Professor Feldman, do you agree with that? Professor Feldman: I do. Subsections (8) and (9) have twin disadvantages. First, they try to create a presumption that something will…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (First sitting)Q Finally, I will ask the same question that I asked the previous panel about ouster, and the Government’s comment in a press release that the “text that removes the Cart judgment…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (First sitting)For either, or both. Professor Feldman: I will start then, if I may. I think there is a real difficulty about a provision of this kind being used as a template, because there are…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Except that in some cases there will be pro bono representation, or there may be privately paid representation. Is this a level playing field? I am talking about the minority of…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Mr Leiper, am I okay to ask you about employment tribunals? Richard Leiper: You can.02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Yes, Chair, just for completeness. This panel probably expected to deal primarily with part 1 of the Bill, so this question is for any of the witnesses, but I am guessing that…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q Our notes say that I can, so I will have a try. Do you welcome the provisions in clauses 32 to 36? Do you see any problems with them, or are they mainly administrative? Richard…02 Nov 2021HANSARDJudicial Review and Courts Bill (Second sitting)Q It looks like it moves responsibility from the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy to the Ministry of Justice, making adjustments to the procedural rules so…02 Nov 2021